2011 Team To Beat

[Phantom]

appreciate it j959. I agree maybe knights at his price is too good to refuse.

[Phantom]

i have made 2 changes that i am reasonably happy with.
Gray-out Knights in
I.Smith -out  Petterd in-

thoughts?

[Luigi197]

i have made 2 changes that i am reasonably happy with.
Gray-out Knights in
I.Smith -out  Petterd in-

thoughts?

not sure about Petterd, wouldve stuck with Smith until further info on either players..

[Phantom]

i will have to monitor both in the NAB.

[mophead222]

i agree with luigi, keep smith and upgrade waite.
Waite can be very good but is it worth the tribunal risks when you dont even have a F/B MPP to like him with??

[Phantom]

hmm interesting, i can't see anyone in the defensive premium range better than Waite. Lake possibly but i don't know. Malceski? Gilbee? i think waite will outscore them all providing he stays out of trouble.

[Junktimer]

backs: all good.

mids: not sure about wallis.  rodney eade has a bad history of playing first year players. -0.5

rucks: all good.

fwds: Don't like petterd.  very injury prone and all though he average 84 this year, he only played 6 games.  I also think he wont get the 40% discount and hence will be more expensive than he is the fanplanner.  I would trade him for Prestia.  -0.5

Overall, very good team, 9/10

can you rate mine?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23368.0.html