Swallow v bennell

[bomberboy0618]

Because of the bye this year ( and to think what fun could be had swallow and bennell in the same mid) I have been forced to choose 1. Which is the better pick? Swallow is a readiness star, but bennell should shine. So who should I go for?

[Justin Bieber]

Swallow is hands down my favourite to pick. Was the shining light in the rather dismal year the Suns had in the VFL.

Bennell will no doubt be great also but Swallow deserves the number 1 pick for a reason. Following in his brother's footsteps 8).

P.S Nice to see you joined up 8).

[bomberboy0618]

Thanks I love this forum there are so many people on always :)

[Maca24]

welcome bomberboy  :) id go swallow mate. also i dont think its a huge sin if you pick both. but yea swallow is better.

[bomberboy0618]

I'd love to go both but the bye :( if only they had brought both teams in at once. And thanks :)
I thought is it better to pick them on the field or bench so that u know what the rookies on your bench should be?

[MTTY]

D.Swallow
Pros
.Does everything well
.Can kick goals
.Accurate kick
.Should average 85+

Cons
.None

Bennell
.Can get a ton of possies
.Can kick bags of goals while playing in the middle and still racking up 25+ possies

Cons
.Will ave (IMO) less then Swallow 70+



I am going with Swallow and Gaff

Gaff due to his huge efficency and his JUDD like Hard ball get skills

[bomberboy0618]

85!!! Let me have some of that :)

[Maca24]

I'd love to go both but the bye :( if only they had brought both teams in at once. And thanks :)
I thought is it better to pick them on the field or bench so that u know what the rookies on your bench should be?

put them on the field if you get either. save the bench for 100k players.

[MTTY]

85!!! Let me have some of that :)

HE'S THAT GOOD!!!!!!!! ;D

[Justin Bieber]

He's Barlow Good ;). Yes, I'm going there 8).

[bomberboy0618]

He's Barlow Good ;). Yes, I'm going there 8).

REBEL!!

[ossie85]

Whoever gets the most preseason points will get selected from me!

How about you add a poll :)

[bomberboy0618]

Will do :)

[S_Coach99]

I'd love to go both but the bye :( if only they had brought both teams in at once. And thanks :)
I thought is it better to pick them on the field or bench so that u know what the rookies on your bench should be?

depends on when the bye is... could be towards the end, then you could have two cash cows with the view of keeping one maybe, then you get almost a full season for the test run

[Fletch74]

Swallow by a country mile.