2011 Player Profile: Travis Cloke

[CrowsFan]

I don't think I will be selecting him in my squad. I have just always found him too inconsistent with his scoring, plus with the big ape Chris Dawes stepping up as another forward option for them he may start seeing less of the ball as they can target Dawes in the forward 50 too. Plus I would prefer to pick either Didak or Thomas in my forward line

[Maca24]

definitely wont be starting him. no!  :)

[tom_scully]

I don't think I will be selecting him in my squad. I have just always found him too inconsistent with his scoring, plus with the big ape Chris Dawes stepping up as another forward option for them he may start seeing less of the ball as they can target Dawes in the forward 50 too. Plus I would prefer to pick either Didak or Thomas in my forward line

yeah, there are much more valuable Pies options.

[Justin Bieber]

Quote from: djtranny on Yesterday at 10:40:14 AM
definite no from me

Me too.

Does the poll option render these responses unnecessary or am I just getting old and grumpy?!??

I was looking forward to some new insight on Mr Cloke. To my dismay I get a poll vote in the form of a comment. That is 5 seconds I will never get back....

Maybe a bit of both :P. Would be better if people added something to the discussion to say why they agree ;).

[Master Q]

If Collingwood have any smart coaches (Which I doubt) and actually tell Cloke how to kick, maybe.

You raise a good point Q, Carlton's superb coaching brain trust have really done with your fantastic forward Mr Fevola-Henderson-Betts-Yarran-Gartlett. What a star they are! Almost as good as Carlton's ability to be better than Collingwood.

8) You are so Smart Ossie