Huge Call- Wayne Carey =???

[Alex7089]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/dane-swan-better-than-nathan-buckley-wayne-carey/story-e6frf9jf-1225903654100
Collingwood players & Wayne Carey saying the great Dane is better than Bucks!!! Swan is a great player, don't get me wrong, but he is no where near as good as him... Yet. He could get there but at the moment I would rather have BUcks than Swan.

[CFC 1979]

Alex you'll start a riot

[Boomz]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/dane-swan-better-than-nathan-buckley-wayne-carey/story-e6frf9jf-1225903654100
Collingwood players & Wayne Carey saying the great Dane is better than Bucks!!! Swan is a great player, don't get me wrong, but he is no where near as good as him... Yet. He could get there but at the moment I would rather have BUcks than Swan.

Not a fan of either of them but is he ***** mad?!

[ossie85]

Bucks at this point, easily.

But a few more seasons like this and ask me again. The answer will still be Bucks, but only just!

[Cruiseon]

If Swan can pull a Brownlow and a flag this year then I'll be more than happy to debate.

Here's hoping we can have such a debate shortly.  8)

[Alex7089]

If Swan can pull a Brownlow and a flag this year then I'll be more than happy to debate.

Here's hoping we can have such a debate shortly.  8)

Indeed, it is great just watching players like Bucks & Swan from a third party view, where you can just admire them.

[Master Q]

They must be kidding me. Bucks is one of the few Collingwood players I admire, the only thing I hate is that he is so bias.

[CFC 1979]

Bucks easily

he was fluid, great kick and strong captain just to name a few

swanny's got a big engine that at this stage nobody can match but hasn't got the silky skills of bucks

ps; but still a great DT + SC pick up

[Alex7089]

For sure Swan is the new SC/DT king! :o
But no way he has reached those heights yet...

[ossie85]

Bucks was a SC/DT God also.

[Alex7089]

Indeed he was, I'm sure, I didn't play either when he was still around so I wouldn't really know but yeah I have seen him play and can imagine he would be a complete SC/DT god.