possible trade

[dylan84]

butler(wce) and s.hill(freo) out

a.otten(adl) and s. mcmahon(nth)


what ya think????

[footyfan2009]

I reckon you shoul definitely get rid of butler, he is a crab. Hill could be ok, he showed a lot of potential in the pre season!

[pgillw]

Don't listen to footyfan2009 - he is a peanut.

Hill is a cat, and needs a couple of years before he'll make any real impact amongst the men.  More important to get Hill out than Butler bc if Hill plays, he loses you $$$ (presumably, break-evens are not up yet).

Depending on where you have Hill, I would think twice before S McMahon.  Consider Petrenko if back (cheap, showed a lot second half, and) and waiting for Beams / Zaharakis to show consistent form next week.  The Z-man could be a DT star.

Also, footyfan2009 is a knob jockey backing in Freo players even though Hill is currently a joke of a footballer.

[selwood09]

i agree that hill is probly a dud, but fanfooty could be right you know, hill did score a 79 in pre season, maybe he just needs a few weeks to adapt to the lift in intensity, i wouldnt keep hill myself, but if someone else wants to take the risk it could pay off