what would you do?

Started by thatguy, July 12, 2010, 10:26:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

what is the better option?

straight swap ziebell to chappy
3 (75%)
ziebell to goodes, then luke ball to boyd
1 (25%)

Total Members Voted: 1

thatguy

im thinking two options this week.

either a straight swap of ziebell to chapman OR

trade ziebell for goodes, then upgrade Luke Ball to Boyd/Ablett.

has goodes turned the corner??
will chappy hold up??
can luke ball deliver some tons again??

6 trades left, last trading session before finals for me.



the first gives me 5 trades left, the second 4, wouldnt touch again until finals unless someone goes down with a LTI.


benjy251090

i would do option 2 but to boyd not ablett as they might rest ablett and they might rest chappy as well, and taken from this roos should play goodes more in the mids now, if he doesnt he is silly and goodes is now as cheap as he is going to be for a while at least

NADO95

I'd say Ball is a keeper and you really shouldn't be trading keepers at all let alone when you have only 6 trades left option 1

thatguy

given how the season has panned out having 6 trades now is good, my team is set other than the one spot in the forward line.

ball is going to get traded at some stage (barring half my side getting hit with injuries) just a matter of either now or on the eve of the finals

Flame

I have Ball too and have been thinking of trading him after his 70 and 79.

I also have 6 trades left.

I thought he was a keeper but he has been disappointing, and Chappy just keeps delivering..

Chappy's hammies are he only thing stopping me!! It sounds like a good option though.