Josh Kennedy?

Started by Master Q, July 09, 2010, 10:03:50 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

wooly

Quote from: Master Q on July 09, 2010, 11:06:08 AM
Nope can't pick up Slyvia atm, but Judd is very cheap at 391k.

How about this:

Barlow ---> Judd
Fyfe ---> Slyvia

Thoughts?

I think its better than the Dal Santo/ JJ or Tippett option.

If you need more convincing:

Judd - 106 average
Sylvia - 83 average

vs.

Nick Dal - 102 average
JJ - 75 average
Tippett - 63 average

Obviously averages aren't always the best measure of a players ability (for example Tippett is in form atm but struggled early in the year) but I still think this is your best bet.

Just make sure you check the final teams this afternoon to make sure Sylvia is playing (highly doubt he won't though).

wooly

Quote from: woozie10 on July 09, 2010, 11:09:41 AM
I'd go Goodes or Higgins over Sylvia.
But if i was in your situation, I'd do:
Barlow to NDS
Fyfe to LeCras

woozie10 makes a good point Goodes and Higgins (is injury prone though - just something to think about) would also be good, but I still wouldn't go NDS/ LeCras over Judd/Sylvia or Goodes or Higgins.

Master Q

Pulls out Calculator -

7.3k in the bank

Barlow - Judd = 63k) + 7.3 = 70.3k

Fyfe, 261.2k + 70.3k =  331.5. Options at that price range include:

Pods (326.8k)

Goodes (MPP  :) 326.3k )

Sylvia ( MPP  :) 324.6k  )

Higgins ( MPP  :) 314.3k )

Master Q

Basically saying that it's between Pods, Goodes,Sylvia and Higgins.

wooly

Quote from: Master Q on July 09, 2010, 11:18:02 AM
Pulls out Calculator -

7.3k in the bank

Barlow - Judd = 63k) + 7.3 = 70.3k

Fyfe, 261.2k + 70.3k =  331.5. Options at that price range include:

Pods (326.8k)

Goodes (MPP  :) 326.3k )

Sylvia ( MPP  :) 324.6k  )

Higgins ( MPP  :) 314.3k )

You don't have Pods?

My thoughts on them (in the order I'd pick them up in):

1) Pods - the pick of the bunch, however I think his chances of getting rested are pretty high; I mean this is essentially his rookie year and he got rested earlier in the year. All depends on whether Geelong secures first spot early or not.

2) Goodes - out of form but still scoring alright. Obviously won't get rested and is extremely durable. And as you mentioned MPP.

3) Sylvia - will score highly but have the odd low scoring game. I think that with all the time he's had off he will fire for the remainder of the year. Usually pretty durable apart from the freak toe injury. MPP

4) Higgins - injury prone, but a good scorer. If you have trades I'd get him ahead of Sylvia as he will be more consistent. MPP

Really can't lose with any of them.

Master Q

Goodes out of form as you said, always worried about Pods that's why I didn't get him. I prefer Higgo over Sylvia, so it's gonna end up like:

Barlow ---> Judd
Fyfe ----> Higgins  :)

wooly

Quote from: Master Q on July 09, 2010, 11:28:01 AM
Goodes out of form as you said, always worried about Pods that's why I didn't get him. I prefer Higgo over Sylvia, so it's gonna end up like:

Barlow ---> Judd
Fyfe ----> Higgins  :)

Sounds good, hope it works out for you :)

woozie10

Sounds good. Good luck :)

Master Q


chrisuzz

Time to get the JPod Q?