JUDD vs SIMPSON!?

[andy_clo]

So i know a lot of coaches have been jumping on the Kade Simpson bandwagon after a strong showing in the NAB games.

What i want to know is whether you think he is actually better than Judd in DT. I know a lot have people have bagged Judd for his poor DT returns but on stats alone he averaged 5 more points than Simpson in 2008. He is also an absolute jet player and despite the tag will always find the footy.

Simpson while good and unlikely to recieve a hard tag is not an absolute gun and may score as low as 40 some weeks.
Can you afford to have Simpson as a 4th mid or would you rather go with Judd who will most likely score 80 most weeks?
Love to hear your opinions on who and why you chose, if any. Or if you have any other suggestions around that price range for a 4th mid.

[andy_clo]

no one has any opinions on s-train or j-rock!!!!???

[Aminal]

I think simpson is quite overrated. When scotland and carrazzo both come back i think he'll find alot less of the ball. Judd hands down imo