Main Menu

How did Barry Hall get off? MRP sympathy?

Started by nick33, May 25, 2010, 11:39:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

nick33

How did Barry Hall get off? Maybe the MRP showed their human-side with a touch of sympathy? quite staggering really though.

http://www.theroar.com.au/2010/05/25/match-review-panel-sympathy-lets-hall-off-the-hook/
QuoteBarry Hall has received an overwhelmingly symphatetic response from the public following his misconduct report on Saturday. But few of us expected that sympathy to extend to the Match Review Panel who raised more than a few eyebrows when they determined his sanction on Monday night.

Hall’s actions have been widely discussed, especially in light of the provocation from North Melbourne defender Scott Thompson which triggered his reaction.

It’s hard to find a context where a twenty-second iron-clamp headlock can be justified, but Hall has found his symphathizers.click here to read the full storyhttp://www.theroar.com.au/2010/05/25/match-review-panel-sympathy-lets-hall-off-the-hook/

valkorum

I thought it was the right decision.  What else was he supposed to do?  The umpires were definitely not calling free kicks his way (which according to the rules should have been payed)

ossie85


He got off, he deserved to get off. He should have been suspended for the 2005 GF though!

Justin Bieber

Didn't deserve to get weeks unless Thompson ended up in hospital ;D.

He was being targetted by the Roo's guys and what was he suppose to do? Crawl up in the goal square? He did what any man would do, stand up for themselves.

Deserved the fine for getting Thompson in a headlock. I'm more suprised in the fact 4 other Roo players came and still couldn't get him off :P

Alex7089

LOL why is he going to get weeks. 3 North players all over him then another couple come and then 30 secs later BRENNAN STACK finally gives him a bit of backup. Doggies no sense of teamwork. Didn't deserve weeks.

bunyip

I reckon Thompson should have been fined for starting it. Pushing guys over while they're doing up their laces is school yard stuff.

PowerMan

some of you adelaide supporters are bitter aren't you's, after Hall whacked Rutten in the chops!

Grow up! Hall deserved to get off, if he got games it would've been an a joke.

kalani