How far from a competitive team?

Started by GregWyatt, March 23, 2009, 10:39:23 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

GregWyatt

Def: L Gilbee, C Cornes, J Drummond, T Lockyer, S Stevens, A Raines, J Geary (K Cheney,  Petrenko)
Mid: J Corey, N Dal Santo, N Foley, J Ad*****, T.Tuck, S Hill (Dangerfield, Rich)
Ruck: D Cox, T Simmonds (Graham, Spencer)
Fwd: J Brown, P Chapman, M Richardson, D Thomas, S Lucas, S Higgins, T Hentschel (T Walker, S Gumbleton)

I've played around fairly well, how far am i from having a fairly competitive team

Al

Lockyer isn't as good as you would think, same with Stevens. I would replace them.

Personally I think Corey has reached his peak and at his price is a bit of a risk. Dal Santo is either inconsistent or consistently shower. Adcock is better off in defence, maybe for Lockyer.

Dale Thomas is a waste of money, though he would be better in SC than DT. Lucas' pre season form suggests he may actually be 40 years old. Gumby is injured and anyway I can't see him getting meaningful points with Lucas, Lloyd and Neagle performing similiar roles.

GregWyatt

Well i just did a fair overhaul of my team..


Def: Hodge, C Cornes, Goddard, Adcock, Houlihan, A Raines, J Geary (Broughton,  Petrenko)
Mid: Bartel, Cooney, Hayes, Foley, Skipworth, S Hill (Dangerfield, Rich)
Ruck: D Cox, T Simmonds (Graham, Spencer)
Fwd: J Brown, P Chapman, M Richardson, Harvey, Yarran, S Higgins, T Hentschel (T Walker, S Gumbleton)

and have no idea who to trade gumbleton for, other one i heard about is ballantyne but hes injured to i think