Everyones opinion?!

Started by team_pav, February 10, 2009, 12:38:27 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

team_pav

Hi all,
this is my current SC squad with just 17,000 left in bank.
All opinions and thoughts welcome!

BACKS:
B. Goddard
L. Gilbee
H. Shaw
C. Cornes
J. Adcock
N. Malceski
S. Hill

N. Suban
J. Petrenko

MIDS:
S. Pendlebury
S. Thompson
B. Cousins
P. Hasleby
S. Higgins
D. Rich

J. Ziebell
T. Swift

RUCKS:
D. Cox
M. Leuenberger

J. White
D. Currie

FORWARDS:
B. Harvey
L. Franklin
B. Deledio
C. Rioli
M. Campbell
S. Lucas
C. Yarran

S. Sidebottom
H. Ballantyne

Disco

Seems like a well balanced side but Luenberger as 2nd ruck is questionable. Ladley takes time to play rookies so I would swap Ziebell for someone else. Ballantyne is injured and may miss first few matches. Other than that it is a good team.

fyfebe

good solid team imo, maybe the only thing i can think of is downgrading one of ur backs and upgrading cousins/hasleby, could be a bit iffy having both in your starting 22, when Ziebell and Swift are far from certanties.

edit: and yea, your second ruck is a bit iffy too :S

team_pav

Yeah ziebell is no certainty, however if he has a good preseason id say hes a good chance to play.
your right about that fyfebe, basically if cousins plays well in the nab hes locked in, if he struggles then i think ill play hasleby instead.
but i suggest you both consider leuenberger, hes very cheap and ive heard that hes been tearing up the training track down in brisbane. if im not convinced when i watch him play though i think ill upgrade to mcintosh.

cheers!