Gibbs Vs K Cornes Vs Kerr

Started by cooney17, March 21, 2009, 06:44:15 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

cooney17

Which is most likely to score highest?
I have Kerr atm

Marcus

What is with people still going with Kerr?
Nothing has changed in WC since last year.
Kerr has gotten older and missed out on playing most of last year.
He was SUSPENDED FROM 6 GAMES because HE GOT FRUSTRATED WITH THE TAG AND TOOK IT OUT ON PLAYERS.
I caps'd it to emphasize my point by the way.
He was SUSPENDED FROM 6 GAMES because HE GOT FRUSTRATED WITH THE TAG AND TOOK IT OUT ON PLAYERS.
And repetition again to emphasize my point.
He is still going to get the number 1 tag. He is still going to be frustrated. He is is not going to return to his previously high scores. He is probably going to get suspended again.
Last year I went with Judd after he moved to a new club and was recovering from injury. BECAUSE HE IS A GREAT PLAYER AND WON A BROWNLOW.
This year I probably will go with Cousins after he has moved to a new club and has spent a year off the field. BECAUSE HE IS A GREAT PLAYER AND WON A BROWNLOW.
Also both are headed into teams that POSSESS THE ABILITY TO MAKE THE TOP 8.
Kerr was GOOD because he had a great ball feed, Cox, along with 2 Brownlow medalists, alongside him. BUT THEY ARE GONE.
Sorry if this post was a bit strong. I shouldn't get annoyed that people don't take advice that will help them be competitive against me.
But I want to drive the point home. Kerr is a no go.
Between therefore Gibbs and K.Cornes. I'll go Gibbs. Has more room to improve I reckon.

Cool9

I don't have Kerr ... but I am watching him closely as I was last year. At his best he is in Judd / Ablett's class, and I think that sooner or later he will figure out how to deal with tags like those blokes. When he does, look out below!
If he's learnt anything from last year he could be dynamite. However, the ever-present risk with Kerr is he hasn't learned a damn thing.

Cool9

Hey Marcus, agree with your points. At $600k you wouldn't go near him, but at $482k he is cheap. He won't do worse than that price, and he could very well do a whole lot better. Won't have to do much to improve on last year, anyway.

cooney17


Bo

Marcus... what exactly are you trying to say ?

Marcus

@Bo: Don't get Kerr get Gibbs out of the three.

DobbosDevils

Kane Cornes is at the top of his game and I can't see a great deal of improvement. Gibbs is at the bottom and I think has a lot of improving to do. I rate him highly as a fantasy footballer. Kerr - well Kerr is Kerr. - and I have never been a fan.