r.Murphy OR m.Duncan?

[keiranrib]

i've got murphy from the dogs in my dream team, but his dismal performance of 33 last round has got me wondering, leave him in my team or bring in mitch duncan who is a reserve. OR should i just trade him?

[peanut]

While I have Duncan and love him for what he's done value wise, I do get nervous when the Cats get named each week, simply because it's almost too good to be true.

Surely at some point they'll 'rest' him int the two's or he'll have a quiet form slump.

I reckon with the cheap kids you get them in your original team or trade one/two in before the price change.

Murphy will come good, the Dogs have a tough run at the momet so just grin and bare it.

[peanut]

ah, just realised you already have Duncan.

base it on who they are playing, Murphy has te pitiful rows this week so leave him on.

Next week they have the Saints so that's a different call. 

[daddsy404]

when in doubt always stick with the proven performer is my theory, and also with the 300+ grand price difference having murphy on the bench is just a waste

either downgrade murphy to pods if u think duncan is the better player, or leave it as is

[elxam]

always stick with proven prems, always!

[daddsy404]

too true elxam, too true