GAblett vs Chapman vs Bartel

[Iceman2151]

Now we all know that most people will always pick Ablett as captain.

To stem the flow of how much Ablett outdoes everyone by, who would be the better pick between Chappy and Bartel to try and hold the flag up against Ablett??
In saying that round scores are as follow
Ablett       Chapman        Bartel
129           105                 114
120           102                 132
130           146                 92
133           127                 109


Now in saying that if you add them up Ablett: 512, Chapman 480 and Bartel 447. Wouldn't you pick Chapman over Bartel?? If not why? Recent form would suggest Chappy would do better than picking Bartel aswell.

Thoughts?

[elxam]

hard to call. bartel will give you 22 games while chappy about 18 but with a higher ave per rd.

would go bartel first for stability