Tidy Up Trades

[Longy88]

Im looking to do my first to trades for the year,

Hurn-Malceski
Clark-Sandi

OR

Ball - Mackenzie
Hall-Brown

OR

Clark-Seaby
Then the Brown trade

Thoughts?

[Griffo1982]

hard to split
Hurn-Malceski
Clark-Sandi
&
Clark-Seaby
Then the Brown trade
but i'm leaning towards the 1st one for no particular reason

[powerade_0]

im leaning more towards the second option. to me the 1st one looks too much like 2 sideways trades

[Longy88]

I did the first in supercoach but i dont like Eski's dt scoring  :-\

[CFC 1979]

loose clark - i do not think there is any hope of good scores for him this year

then save your trades
sit on your hands
you will need then

[Gava]

im looking at the 2nd trade, except instead of hall, its jack ziebell

[MissPiesFF]

Im looking to do my first to trades for the year,

Hurn-Malceski - i can understand this trade
Clark-Sandi -  as I can this one

OR

Ball - Mackenzie Ball will step up this week vs his old team mates. He is NOT the most consisten tplayer nor is he fine and grand, give him a chance
Hall-Brown- is there no one else you can trade for brown ?

OR

Clark-Seaby no brainer do it!!
Then the Brown trade

Thoughts?

[Master Q]

Who's your other ruck?
MP hurn is injured and eski will rise.
Sandi is well sandi.

No need to get rid of Hall, he will come good.

[MissPiesFF]

my point exactly..maybe there is someone else he can trade to brown..but not hall :)

[Big_Cox14]

MP hurn is injured

Hurn isn't injured. He's just been suspended for two weeks.

[MissPiesFF]

Longy may I ask who you have on the bench in these instances?

[Big_Cox14]

Hurn-Malceski
Clark-Sandi

OR

Ball - Mackenzie
Hall-Brown

OR

Clark-Seaby
Then the Brown trade

The first option you're trading Hurn who isn't actually injured. Only suspended for two weeks. He's a keeper! The second option you're trading a proven player in Ball for an unproven in McKenzie. Will McKenzie keep up his tackle count? Whereas, third option Clark is underperforming & Seaby is performing well & looks like he suits the Swans gameplan. Brown is a keeper, but I think that it's a bit premature to trade Hall. So option 3 is probably the best out of the 3 options.

[Flame]

Yep..Option 3 for me!! Brown's price will rise this week and Seaby looks good for the Season..

[Cicjose]

now everyone will need to make a trade this week with Riewoldt tearing his hamstring off the bone against Collingwood in tonight's game. I'm glad i picked barlow as captain :)

[Master Q]

MP hurn is injured

Hurn isn't injured. He's just been suspended for two weeks.

Sorry, meant to type that :-[