Feedback appreciated

[neeld]

Enright
hodge
waite
Kennelly
malceski
ladson
hunt

waters
silvagni

ablett
pendlebury
j.selwood
bartel
barlow
Martin

Duncan
mcneil

sandilands
naitanui

warnock
lobbe

pavlich
Harvey
higgins
gray
Tippett
dangerfield
ziebell

gumbleton
Weston

[neeld]

a lot of people happy to read but not comment? no news is good news imho

[Slashers]

Maybe you don't want my opinion  :-X

This goes for everyone else that has done the same.

I hate the common Kennelly, malceski, ladson, hunt, waters picks!
How about we just nickname them Irishman, knee, both knees!, ACL, elbow&knee. I have a bad feeling about a few of them.

I have none of them in my team - and I will be better for it. (nope, I'm not naming who I do have just yet!  8))

Nice mids & rucks.

Too many S.A. players in your forwards (LOL), but nice to see you don't have Gia (again, many other unique pick - just have to open your eyes).

We didn't need 5 cheap ex-injured backs and half a dozen rookie mids last year?

[ossie85]

Lock out is done :)

I'd wait until the end of round 1 before deciding what to do next!

[neeld]

Maybe you don't want my opinion  :-X

This goes for everyone else that has done the same.

I hate the common Kennelly, malceski, ladson, hunt, waters picks!
How about we just nickname them Irishman, knee, both knees!, ACL, elbow&knee. I have a bad feeling about a few of them.

I have none of them in my team - and I will be better for it. (nope, I'm not naming who I do have just yet!  8))

Nice mids & rucks.

Too many S.A. players in your forwards (LOL), but nice to see you don't have Gia (again, many other unique pick - just have to open your eyes).

We didn't need 5 cheap ex-injured backs and half a dozen rookie mids last year?

no im happy for the feedback, cheers. i dont pick on what others have or dont have in their team, i pick on merit only.

who were the injured backs? i got 4 rookie mids

[HillHero13]

8.5/10

[neeld]

Hodge
Waite
Kennelly
Malceski
Ladson
J.Hunt

Waters
Silvagni

Ablett
M.Murphy
J.Selwood
Bartel
Martin
Barlow

Duncan
McNeil

Sandilands
Naitanui

Warnock
Lobbe

J.Brown
B.Harvey
Higgins
Gray
Tippett
Dangerfield
Ziebell

Gumbleton
Weston

[Griffo1982]

Hodge
Waite - i'd look at 1 other premium in the backline that arent coming back from injury eg enright, carrazzo, Goddard
Kennelly
Malceski
Ladson
J.Hunt - I'd have Waters on the ground in place of Hunt or Ladson

Waters - I'd have Macguire on the bench
Silvagni

Ablett
M.Murphy
J.Selwood
Bartel
Martin
Barlow

Duncan - Banner, Shuey, Bastinac, Morabito, Trengrove, Jetta i think are all better options than who you have on your bench
McNeil

Sandilands
Naitanui

Warnock
Lobbe

J.Brown
B.Harvey - Ditch him, cant handle tags anymore
Higgins - a little injury prone, will miss 3-4 games with weak soft tissue problems
Gray - same as above
Tippett - horrible form & not sure if he can get out of it
Dangerfield - great choice
Ziebell - will be inconsistent

Gumbleton
Weston - i'd pick hitchcock & maybe Rockcliff depending on how he goes on the weekend & the next couple of games if Voss gives him a decent go.

6/10

[Master Q]

Hodge
Waite
Kennelly Trade out later
Malceski
Ladson
J.Hunt Stick with him

Waters
Silvagni

Ablett - Spent to much money on him with a strong midfield
M.Murphy
J.Selwood
Bartel
Martin Isn't performing unlike other rookies
Barlow

Duncan Shuey, Bastinac
McNeilBanner?

Sandilands
Naitanui

Warnock
Lobbe

J.Brown
B.Harvey Gulp!
Higgins
Gray
Tippett
Dangerfield Did you take out Hall? If so, waste of a trade
Ziebell

Gumbleton
Weston

[neeld]

nah, only traded murphy for pendles and jbrown for pav... dangerf was in without hairy ball from the start

[haooyy]

Pretty solid apart from a few worries. Gray, Harvey and Tippett in the forward line are big worries - I would consider trading Gray if he's not in the Port team by next week (try Shannon Byrnes), it'll take him a couple of weeks to find his feet, and you can't rely on Gumbleton as a starter for too long. But then again, you've used 2 trades already, which isn't great, trading Pendlebury for Murphy was definitely a wasted trade this early on considering Pendles isn't struggling with neither form nor injury. Duncan would've been better chosen in the forward line considering the plethora of good rookies in the midfield. I would also deduct a mark for having neither of Goddard and Riewoldt, but hey that's just me  :P

6/10