Mid priced mids

Started by StanMan, March 17, 2009, 08:40:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

StanMan

Haselby, Rielly, Masten or T Tuck???

fyfebe

Definately Tuck, great injury free off season, locked himself into Hawthorns 22. Reilly is too injury prone, Hasleby is coming off a long term injury, Masten has OP problems + pulled up sore after the game on the weekend.

ando10

alot of people are mentioning reilly whats the word on him?

id say tuck

i have masten though only cuz of cash

Bo

The order i'd run would be

#1 Hasleby
#2 Reilly
#3 Cale Morton
#4 Masten
#5 Tuck


First two are top notch, second two are guaranteed heaps of game time, and get alot of the ball, tuck is good but so is his team, might get limited minutes, i'd have him last there, but thats just my interpretation.

ando10

#1 tuck
#2 hasleby
#3 masten
#4 reilly
# morton

bluebaggas

i dont agree with Bo
hawthorn dont have a particularly strong midfield
their only gun is mitchel and maybe sewel
then there is bateman, lewis and young
the way i see it clarkson needs to  develop a good kid into a gun
and tuck would be the standout for me

Bo

Sure he might make monty's first team for round 1, but...

Injured: Trent Croad, Xavier Ellis, Tim Boyle, Rick Ladson, Stephen Gilham, Jordan Lewis, McGlynn

Waiting: Morton, Beau Dowler, Josh P. Kennedy, Garry Moss
are also fighting for a spot in the side.

Morton and Kennedy are actually quite good too, i dont have any info on the other two.

The other 4 players will play every game bar injury. Youd hate to pick up tuck and have him play a bad game or two mid season and get pushed out for X.Ellis or J. Lewis to come back in, or somesuch. Just my opinion. It is important that he plays as much as possible considering he's in your main team.

bjrouse

Quote from: Bo on March 17, 2009, 10:15:50 AM
Sure he might make monty's first team for round 1, but...

Injured: Trent Croad, Xavier Ellis, Tim Boyle, Rick Ladson, Stephen Gilham, Jordan Lewis, McGlynn

Waiting: Morton, Beau Dowler, Josh P. Kennedy, Garry Moss
are also fighting for a spot in the side.

Morton and Kennedy are actually quite good too, i dont have any info on the other two.

The other 4 players will play every game bar injury. Youd hate to pick up tuck and have him play a bad game or two mid season and get pushed out for X.Ellis or J. Lewis to come back in, or somesuch. Just my opinion. It is important that he plays as much as possible considering he's in your main team.

very good point