Brouch vs Libba vs Walsh - who goes first?

[Holz]

Just looking at his stats it's pretty obvious what is going on with Libba

1 tackle last week, and just 1 the week before

2 tackles in 2 weeks? That's probably a record low for him

Only had 14 touches on the weekend too which is well below his average

I can certainly understand why people are trading him to Fyfe etc now, but I'm getting all the spud rookies out first before I look at upgrading him, and if his value drops in the meantime then so be it - will eventually ton up soon I'm sure and stem the bleeding - I still have faith he will be good enough for M8/9 and be a keeper

yeah i think if you have spud rookies then better to drop them

but if its getting rid of guys like Durrs, Drew etc.. i think he has to go.

You would rather keep Duursma? That's strange considering there's Answerth available who looks the perfect like for like swap. Holding Drew I can understand because he's a 3rd year mid who has forward status.

Even if Libba drops a little he's still destined to average somewhere in the 90's, when the byes roll around his value will be felt I reckon.

Is he destined to average in the 90s?

He went 90 in 2015. He went 79 in 2017 and haa gone 75 in the last 3 rounds.

If you think he goes 95+ keep him if not dump him.

[Wanderer]

The way he has been playing lately he might even get dropped  :P

[Bully]

The way he has been playing lately he might even get dropped  :P

You seriously think he'll get dropped?

My feeling is he deserves the benefit of the doubt, shouldn't bleed too much if he scores a 90 so I'm holding.

[juzztheball]

The way he has been playing lately he might even get dropped  :P

You seriously think he'll get dropped?

My feeling is he deserves the benefit of the doubt, shouldn't bleed too much if he scores a 90 so I'm holding.

No way he'll get dropped... The only person who could come in for him from Footscray is Rhylee West and he's nowhere near ready...

I'm going to back him in to bounce back, Walsh is going...

[Wanderer]

The way he has been playing lately he might even get dropped  :P

You seriously think he'll get dropped?

My feeling is he deserves the benefit of the doubt, shouldn't bleed too much if he scores a 90 so I'm holding.

Seriously, no.

[crowls]

Libba still averaging 98, really surprised at the number of people jumping off.

Tricky one. Atm you still get $161 prof which is about what you want from a stepping stone/trade & if you don't take it now I think you are committed to the long haul. So that is the question I suppose. Bail now or hold until at least his bye.

abandon ship time for sure.   trade now and take what everyone who started him would hace jumped at pre season.   do not look back,  thank you libba!

[_wato]

Other thing for me is that I want Bont so if I'm trading Walsh I'll have Bont, Macrae, Daniel and Libba. Not sure I want to bank on all 4 guys from the same team doing well.

Hedge my bets and ditch Libba over Walsh which gives me Macrae Bont and Daniel.

[Dmoney$]

Fkn hell Lads so hard to choose who gets the flick out of Walsh/b.crouch/Lib
I’m probably tossing up between Libba and Crouch just not sure who.
Crouch will continue to get 30+ possies
Just needs to fix up his efficiency and have more meaningful possessions. Libba on the other hand has proven he can go on consistent scoring runs at times and his dealings higher, but I’m concerned with him being used as a tagged occasionally and spent a bit more time forward last week with Dunkley playing more mid. Help please who do I trade and who do I keep? 

[crowls]

Libber, Walsh, Crouch  or look at your byes and see who you are trading them for and which option strengthens your team over the bye period. 

[Rusty00]

Couldn’t find the thread with the discussion on it, but B Crouch 19SC 33DT at 1/4 time ::)

[crowls]

Couldn’t find the thread with the discussion on it, but B Crouch 19SC 33DT at 1/4 time ::)

same ol same ol for brad