L.Ryan or heater?

[Spotted gum]

Decided ro downgrade Hibbard as it helps me fix up another problem
And am stuck on these two. Think Ryan being a great point of differance and a consistent scorer is great but then Heater is a proven pig.  Thoughts?

[Goosey]

Not much of a sample size with L.Ryan, but plenty of history to back up the choice of Heater.

Don't think I would pick Ryan, but that doesn't mean it couldn't be a good punt to pick him as a POD.

[DunnyBrush]

I haven't actually watched Shaw play this year yet, so i can't say whether his role/scoring is sustainable or  not.
I really like the Luke Ryan pick if R14 bye defenders are not a problem for you.

[quinny88]

Definitely Heater. He's back!

Taking kick ins, peeling off for cheap sideways kicks, running past for handballs. It's the Heater we know and love

[Spotted gum]

My only problem with heater is does his roll change wheen Williams is back in the side?

[fuzeski]

My only problem with heater is does his roll change wheen Williams is back in the side?

Williams is out for the season mate

[tkringle]

My only problem with heater is does his roll change wheen Williams is back in the side?

Williams is out for the season mate

[ubeaut]

Definitely Heater. He's back!

Taking kick ins, peeling off for cheap sideways kicks, running past for handballs. It's the Heater we know and love

God he's annoying, where was this last year when I started him? Can't just blame Williams either. He was lazy,slow disinterested and just stood there yelling at everyone while doing SFA himself.
I don't know if I can trust him, but a trade of Hibberd to Shaw or Simpson is mighty tempting.

[Dir Goose]

Heater no doubt!

[Southstorm]

Would want to see a bit more of Ryan as he won't always be playing against a side that refuses to man a loose player in defence.