To trade or Hold?

[waldorfs wizards]

Really unsure if trades this week are required... billings is the big worry as he is for everyone who has him, open to comments and suggestions!

DEF: Laird, Hurley, Hibberd, Bonner, Doedee, Murrary (naughton, murphy)

MID: Titch, Fyfe, Dusty, Cripps, Conigs, T.Kelly, Holman, Finlayson (brayshaw, banfiled, barry)

RUCK: S. Martin, Gawn (Olango)

FWD: Heeney, Franklin, Billings, D.Smith, Fritsch, Henry (Garlett, Gillies-Langdon)

With $196k in the kitty... really thinking billings to greene but sideways trades are usually a big no! Feel free to give me your throughts

[EA100]

Yeh it’d be pretty risky doing a sideways trade, he’s shown potential in the past, it doesn’t help that st kilda are playing shower house either. But I would look at using that trade and getting rid of Brayshaw for Coffield because he has good JS by the looks of it, has scoring potential, which means he’ll make more money for you then Brayshaw. Also Coffield is both a MID/DEF. if you were to sideways trade then yeh Greene or even Gray would make decent options

[waldorfs wizards]

Yeh it’d be pretty risky doing a sideways trade, he’s shown potential in the past, it doesn’t help that st kilda are playing shower house either. But I would look at using that trade and getting rid of Brayshaw for Coffield because he has good JS by the looks of it, has scoring potential, which means he’ll make more money for you then Brayshaw. Also Coffield is both a MID/DEF. if you were to sideways trade then yeh Greene or even Gray would make decent options

My original trades for the round were billings to Greene then brayshaw to Coff....

Only issue is that it doesnt give me many options to get guelfi and mirra next week as the other rookies will still be making me money.. really stuck between a rock and a hard place

[EA100]

Yeh it’d be pretty risky doing a sideways trade, he’s shown potential in the past, it doesn’t help that st kilda are playing shower house either. But I would look at using that trade and getting rid of Brayshaw for Coffield because he has good JS by the looks of it, has scoring potential, which means he’ll make more money for you then Brayshaw. Also Coffield is both a MID/DEF. if you were to sideways trade then yeh Greene or even Gray would make decent options

My original trades for the round were billings to Greene then brayshaw to Coff....

Only issue is that it doesnt give me many options to get guelfi and mirra next week as the other rookies will still be making me money.. really stuck between a rock and a hard place

Yeh I know what you mean, but I do reckon that by the end of their run in your team Coffield is the best $ option of the three just because I reckon he’ll get enough games to give him that opportunity to go up pretty high if he keeps a decent average.

[Ringo]

I would do the Brayshaw trade. As we have seen other options come along.

Neither Barry or Murphy have played for 2 weeks and if not named next week you can use both to get Mirra and Guelfi.