Been a while

[charms0604]

Hi All

It's been a couple years since I've had a crack at Supercoach. Was wondering what you thought of my first attempt at my team?

B: Hurley Laird Hibberd O'Shea Doedee H.Goddard (Finlayson Mirra)
M: Danger Dusty Mitch Fyfe Cripps Petracca D-Uniacke J.Garlett (Ahern T.Kelly Barry)
R: Gawn Naitanui (English)
F: Billings Dahlhaus D.Smith Christensen Rayner J.Higgins (Fritsch L.Ryan)

Only $20,600 left. Looking to free up my cap
 

[JimMundy93]

I like the structure, however a couple of selections raise eyebrows for me personally

Nic Nat is risky given how volatile his injury, however I assume you are monitoring that situation anyway

I feel like Petracca is someone who should not be selected in the midfield, if you are spending that kind of money I would rather get a Redden or alternatively O'Meara or Armitage are cheaper and all of these players I feel have a higher scoring potential than Christian

Now I am a massive Dees fan and think Petracca will have a great year, but if you want him I would select him as a forward.

Obviously rookies will become more relevant when the teams are announced so no feedback there

Good Luck!

[Money Shot]

I like the structure, however a couple of selections raise eyebrows for me personally

Nic Nat is risky given how volatile his injury, however I assume you are monitoring that situation anyway

I feel like Petracca is someone who should not be selected in the midfield, if you are spending that kind of money I would rather get a Redden or alternatively O'Meara or Armitage are cheaper and all of these players I feel have a higher scoring potential than Christian

Now I am a massive Dees fan and think Petracca will have a great year, but if you want him I would select him as a forward.

Obviously rookies will become more relevant when the teams are announced so no feedback there

Good Luck!

agree with everything above.

[charms0604]

Thinking about what you said this is my team...

B: Hurley Laird Hibberd O'Shea Doedee H.Goddard (Finlayson Mirra)
M: Danger Dusty Mitch Fyfe Cripps O'Meara D-Uniacke J.Garlett (Ahern T.Kelly Barry)
R: Gawn Kreuzer (Cameron)
F: Billings Dahlhaus D.Smith Christensen Rayner J.Higgins (Fritsch L.Ryan)

I solved the Petracca and Nic Nat issue... although bit nervous about O'Meara.. even as a Hawks supporter I have my doubts he will stay injury free past 5 minutes in the season opener.

With Kreuzer... not sure if his statement about playing forward more is true... and if that will impact his numbers

[JimMundy93]

Thinking about what you said this is my team...

B: Hurley Laird Hibberd O'Shea Doedee H.Goddard (Finlayson Mirra)
M: Danger Dusty Mitch Fyfe Cripps O'Meara D-Uniacke J.Garlett (Ahern T.Kelly Barry)
R: Gawn Kreuzer (Cameron)
F: Billings Dahlhaus D.Smith Christensen Rayner J.Higgins (Fritsch L.Ryan)

I solved the Petracca and Nic Nat issue... although bit nervous about O'Meara.. even as a Hawks supporter I have my doubts he will stay injury free past 5 minutes in the season opener.

With Kreuzer... not sure if his statement about playing forward more is true... and if that will impact his numbers

Does not have to be O'Meara Exactly, the point I was making is that Midfielders for Petraccas price are going to score more

Kruezer I am worried about as well just because his high price he has the ability to drop initially if his role is slightly changed

Honestly if I were you I would start one of Martin, Jacobs or Goldy and then if you have the money upgrade O'Meara to Coniglio

[charms0604]

B: Hurley Laird Hibberd O'Shea Doedee H.Goddard (Finlayson Mirra)
M: Danger Dusty Mitch Fyfe Cripps O'Meara D-Uniacke J.Garlett (Ahern T.Kelly Barry)
R: Gawn Jacobs (Olango)
F: Billings Dahlhaus D.Smith Christensen Rayner J.Higgins (Fritsch L.Ryan)

Always been a fan of The Sauce... Jacobs it is.

Will have to work some magic to upgrade O'Meara to a Coniglio type and priced player. Maybe could replace one of my $200k with a rookie once they are named.

O'Meara + The Bank I will have $425,000... any suggestions?

[ubeaut]

Downgrade Rayner to another cheaper fwd rookie. That will free up cash.

[charms0604]

B: Hurley Laird Hibberd O'Shea Doedee H.Goddard (Finlayson Mirra)
M: Danger Dusty Mitch Fyfe Cripps Coniglio D-Uniacke J.Garlett (Ahern T.Kelly Barry)
R: Gawn Jacobs (Olango)
F: Billings Dahlhaus D.Smith Christensen Venables J.Higgins (Fritsch L.Ryan)

Coniglio seems like a popular pick... so I've made the suggested change. Thanks all.

With $50k left would there be a case to bring in Heeney for Billings?

[Bully]

Save that cash for some rookie adjustements eg. Olango up to Cameron if named or Higgins up to Stephenson (I doubt Higgins will play round 1)

[Money Shot]

Yep looks good to me!

[charms0604]

Never one to live dangerously... bit of a shake up of the team

B: Hurley Laird Hibberd Coffield Doedee Naughton (Finlayson Murray)
M: J Kelly Dusty Mitch Fyfe O'Meara Coniglio A Brayshaw J.Garlett (Banfield T.Kelly Holman)
R: Gawn Jacobs (Olango)
F: Billings Heeney D.Smith Christensen Venables Sicily (Fritsch L.Ryan)

O'Shea -> Coffield
Goddard -> Naughton
Mirra -> Murray
Danger -> Kelly
Cripps -> O'Meara
Uniacke -> Brayshaw
Ahern -> Banfield
Barry -> Holman
Dahlhaus -> Heeney
Higgins -> Sicily

Maybe too much sacrifice in the mids to strengthen the forwards