C Curnow vs J Melksham

[valkorum]

Can't believe I am the first to ask a comparison question :)

Who do you think will have a better season between Charlie Curnow and Jake Melksham.  I think both a priced below their 71 average suggests.  I believe I can fit one of these guys in my team but obviously I want to pick the one that will have the better year

At this stage I am tending towards Curnow

Thoughts?

[Mr.Craig]

I'd take Curnow of the two. Melksham has had years to prove he's an 80+ player and has failed to get there. Mind you I wouldn't put it past Curnow to score in the 50's Round 1 vs Richmond, as he did last year.

[jvalles69]

Wouldn't touch either.

[Toga]

I wouldn't be touching either for that price

[Levi434]

Melky is 4 realz

[valkorum]

Sorry about this but have decided to go with neither now.  Downgraded to Cam Rayner and upgraded to another premo midfielder (Treloar).