corkascrew 2018

Started by Corkascrew, February 04, 2018, 10:19:47 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Corkascrew

DEFENDERS
E. Yeo WCE $561,300
R. Laird ADE $550,800
H. Shaw GWS $458,100
N. Wilson FRE $417,300
G. Birchall HAW $277,100
C. O'Shea CAR $166,000

T. Doedee ADE $123,900
S. Murray COL $123,900

MIDFIELDERS
D. Martin RIC $656,000
T. Mitchell HAW $653,500
N. Fyfe FRE $597,900
P. Cripps CAR $537,300
D. Hannebery SYD $535,100
A. Brayshaw MEL $316,700
L. Davies-Uniacke NTH $189,300
J. Higgins RIC $130,800

N. Freeman STK $123,900
T. Kelly GEE $117,300
N. Holman GCS $102,400

RUCKS
M. Gawn MEL $503,700
N. Naitanui WCE $465,900

S. Hayes PTA  $117,300

FORWARDS
I. Heeney SYD  $536,300
L. Dahlhaus WBD $498,500
J. de Goey COL $434,300
A. Christensen BRL $267,300
P. Ahern NTH $123,900
D. Venables WCE $123,900

J. Garlett CAR $117,300
L. Ryan WCE $117,300

Corkascrew

any thoughts or comments much appreciated still unsure on de goey wilson and hanners so they could change everything else pretty happy with

enzedder

Quote from: Corkascrew on February 04, 2018, 10:21:34 AM
any thoughts or comments much appreciated still unsure on de goey wilson and hanners so they could change everything else pretty happy with
Hanners has had a new injury and set back this pre season and is the Swan that has the biggest task ahead of him to be right for R1. Would swap him to Beams and De Goey is the other I'd change. Lobb might be a good one to change him to if he is sole ruck and does well pre season.

Corkascrew

 tossing up between
option a: jake lloyd, coniglio, billings
option b: nathan wilson, hannebry, de goey
option c: hanley, pendelbury, lobb
leaning towards option a but like option b as more pod

enzedder

Quote from: Corkascrew on February 04, 2018, 10:44:05 AM
tossing up between
option a: jake lloyd, coniglio, billings
option b: nathan wilson, hannebry, de goey
option c: hanley, pendelbury, lobb
leaning towards option a but like option b as more pod
a. underpriced good pick/ underpriced good pick/ lock
b. some risk but has merit/ recently injured, interrupted pre season, poor last season/risky pick
c. bad bye, some risk/ hard to say bad things about Pendles but not for me as a starting pick this year/ some risk but likely pick

Easily a for mine

ubeaut

#5
Bit too much money in backline imo. Id drop Heater/Wilson to rookie. Use cash to get Danger/Oliver/Kelly or other for Hanners who isn't fully fit. Maybe Billings in for DeGoey?
Option a for me too.

DCAK

Quote from: Corkascrew on February 04, 2018, 10:19:47 AM
DEFENDERS
E. Yeo WCE $561,300
R. Laird ADE $550,800
H. Shaw GWS $458,100
N. Wilson FRE $417,300
G. Birchall HAW $277,100
C. O'Shea CAR $166,000

T. Doedee ADE $123,900
S. Murray COL $123,900

MIDFIELDERS
D. Martin RIC $656,000
T. Mitchell HAW $653,500
N. Fyfe FRE $597,900
P. Cripps CAR $537,300
D. Hannebery SYD $535,100
A. Brayshaw MEL $316,700
L. Davies-Uniacke NTH $189,300
J. Higgins RIC $130,800

N. Freeman STK $123,900
T. Kelly GEE $117,300
N. Holman GCS $102,400

RUCKS
M. Gawn MEL $503,700
N. Naitanui WCE $465,900

S. Hayes PTA  $117,300

FORWARDS
I. Heeney SYD  $536,300
L. Dahlhaus WBD $498,500
J. de Goey COL $434,300
A. Christensen BRL $267,300
P. Ahern NTH $123,900
D. Venables WCE $123,900

J. Garlett CAR $117,300
L. Ryan WCE $117,300

Hi mate, jeepers.... you've got a bit of risk in your team:
Heater - Coming off an absolulte stinker in 2017, old bloke
Birchall - Coming back from injury, still not in full training, old bloke
Wilson - Speculate pick, never posted premium numbers before
Hannebery - Coming off a stinker in 2017
NicNat - Coming back from injury, currently restricted in training
Dahlhaus - Coming off a stinker in 2017, doubts over role in 2018 (less midfield time in 2017)
Christensen - Coming back from injury, questions over role in 2018 (Fwd/Mid %)

I'm not trying to be a killjoy, I'm just giving a critical analysis of your team. 
Personally, my aim is to go with 'rolled gold' premiums and avoid risk wherever possible

I hope this helps and wish you best of luck for season 2018

Money Shot

This team would have killed 2016. ;)

as for your options, option A without a doubt.

DCAK

Quote from: Corkascrew on February 04, 2018, 10:44:05 AM
tossing up between
option a: jake lloyd, coniglio, billings
option b: nathan wilson, hannebry, de goey
option c: hanley, pendelbury, lobb
leaning towards option a but like option b as more pod

A.