Feedback appreciated

[Jrads11]

Def
Laird
Hibberd
H. Shaw
Birchall
Oshea
Doedee

Mid
Martin
Ablett
J. Kelly
Fyfe
Beams
LDU
W. Brodie
Worple

Rucks
Jacobs
Gawn

Forwards
Heeney
Wingard
Billings
Lobb
Christienson
Higgins

Will pick rookies/bench after jlt

[Money Shot]

Actually a really good side mate.

Ablett is a bit of a risk with injury concerns and I can almost guarantee that he won't play a full season but when he does play he should score 120+.

Wingard is another good pod, only concern is that round 10 bye.

Good team to sit on until JLT.

[shaker]

Yep good first up team but not keen on Wingard seems to be always getting injured and Lobb is looking iffy as well

[Ringo]

Good first up team and ok to sit on.
Just need to monitor Lobb and Heeny,
Wingard will be an up and down ride and Rd 10 bye may be a turn off,

[Jrads11]

Cheers for the feedback guys feel like wingard is gonna explode this year, he has those superstar qualities.  Who would be a replacement for lobb if he doesn't get up? And yeah i do release gaz is a big risk but if he does manage a near full season id be kicking myself not having the champ in my side

[ubeaut]

Nice. Like the different midfield picks. I'd downgrade Lobb to a rookie and replace him with another Mid like in the Bont/Cripps/Pendles price range.

[Jrads11]

Cheers Yeah thinking that mate, and replace who with a bont pricerange mid?

[SilverLion]

Danger?

[ubeaut]

Cheers Yeah thinking that mate, and replace who with a bont pricerange mid?

Lobb > Rookie
Rookie > Bont/ Pendles type or TMitch if u can afford.

[DCAK]

Def
Laird
Hibberd
H. Shaw
Birchall
Oshea
Doedee

Mid
Martin
Ablett
J. Kelly
Fyfe
Beams
LDU
W. Brodie
Worple

Rucks
Jacobs
Gawn

Forwards
Heeney
Wingard
Billings
Lobb
Christienson
Higgins

Will pick rookies/bench after jlt

Howdy bud, here's my thoughts on your team;

Birchall is injured and is not training;
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-01-11/knee-surgery-slows-hawk-defenders-2018

Lobb is injured;
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/afl/rory-lobb-likely-to-miss-round-one-as-gws-injury-curse-enters-third-year/news-story/5fd33582bb55e8df13a6a9fa5b5bd8f5

Otherwise it's pretty good, kudos for the Ablett pick, I think he'll score very well.

[Jrads11]

Post jlt side, forward rookies concerning me a bit

Laird hibbard savage
Naughton finlayson doedee  (keefe, murry)

Martin, mitchell, fyfe, bontempelli
Cripps, coniglio, o'meara, Kelly (barry, worple, holman)

Martin, gawn (olango)

Heeney, billings, d smith, sicily
Fritsch, garlett (venables, ahern)

$700 left

[SilverLion]

Laird hibbard savage
Naughton finlayson doedee  (keefe, murry)

Martin, mitchell, fyfe, bontempelli
Cripps, coniglio, o'meara, Kelly (barry, worple, holman)

Martin, gawn (olango)

Heeney, billings, d smith, sicily
Fritsch, garlett (venables, ahern)

$700 left

Nice side, no Danger the only concern. If you're comfortable with finding a way to get him in mid season then you could be well off.

In terms of rookies, Venables, Worpel and Ahern are unlikely to play Round 1. Would be looking at the round 1 sides closely to see who is.

[RoughRed]

WCE forward rookies pecking order Ryan>Rioli>Venables
Waterman is looking to be an early replacement for Kennedy but will have poor JS

I would be going Ryan But better idea after today WCEvFreo

Keep an eye on Banfield from the Dockers as Worple replacement too

[Jrads11]

WCE forward rookies pecking order Ryan>Rioli>Venables
Waterman is looking to be an early replacement for Kennedy but will have poor JS


I would be going Ryan But better idea after today WCEvFreo

Keep an eye on Banfield from the Dockers as Worple replacement too

Thanks for the advice mate!