Has Bob got it right??? Critisism welcome..

[Bob the builder]

Backs: Goddard Enright Shaw Hodge Kennelly Shoenmakers Waters
(Maguire Silvagni)

Mids: Selwood Mitchell Watson Ball Martin Barlow
(Jetta Banner)

Rucks: Clark Nicnat
(Warnock Lobbe)

Fwds: Reiwoldt ROK Higgins Hall Tippett Dangerfield Medhurst
(Rockliffe Hicthcock)

[Bob the builder]

Not a bad team Bob but no Ablett the obvious omission :o

[Bob the builder]

Thanks for the feed back Bob. At least someone's taking an interest ;D

[Magnus Awesome]

Bob, average at best!!  ::)

[Bob the builder]

What would you change? ???

[Bob the builder]

Yeah valid question Bob, I think it's better the average!!

[Bob the builder]

Any thoughts ????

[CrowsFan]

backs are pretty solid, not too sure about shoenmakers though...
centres are good except as you said yourself no ablett, don't like didak there either, if you are going to have him get him as a forward.
i like your rucks, i have nic nat too
forwards maybe a little week with riewoldt really your only 100+ each week, with all the others you are just hoping they improve. maybe swap didak with higgins and then get a different centre?

[Bob the builder]

Cheers CrowsFan :)

[toodledock]

selwood aint a sc'er

well he is he iw everything, but he is not a specialist like junior

[Pravis]

You can go with the 3 rookie structure so down grade Didak and up grade Selwood to GAJ. Its just too much of a risk not to have GAJ. He will be your lock captain every week and you will loose games when he scores his 200+ as your opponents captain. U pay the extra 150K to make sure you win these games against other people who have him and more importanly people who dont have him.

[Bob the builder]

Thanks lads, can't say I agree with Selwood not being a proven SC'er, but I take your point on GAJ...

[c4v3m4n]

Not a a bad team Bob (Except missing Ablett, which you know by now)

Backs: Nice back line. Sheonmakers will be an interesting one to watch. Has a lot to prove, and he's gonna want to impress. Rumors are he may even move forward at times....

Mids: Didak is an intersting choice. I wonder what effect his scores will have with Ball in the midfield too...maybe sway Didak for Ball?  :P

Rucks: Solid combo, however you may find that Ryders score take a hit with Hille back in the side...

Forwards: I cant help feel that your missing a second premium player like O'Keefe or Brown. Maybe look at downgrading one for say Ballantyne, Warren or Macaffer?

Overall: Its a good team with a few leaks that need fixing. 8.5/10

Good luck and happy supercoaching.

PS. Mind rating mine?
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,10949.0.html

[Bob the builder]

Thanks c4v3m4n,

I have swapped Didak for Ball and upgraded Gray to ROK. Looks pretty solid too me.