Waste of trade or not ???

[Mark]

Hi,

I've had Grimley from Essendon on my bench all year coping donut after donut..

Is it worth wasting a trade and only making $6k and trading in Phillips from
Collingwood to get an extra playing emergency ???

I currently have 7 trades remaining with only Kerridge, Hall and Libba to upgrade but there just comfort trades..

Please vote asap

[djbics]

Haven't voted as while I think it is actually a good trade, with only 7 trades left it may be one you regret down the track, those trades are going to be golden later on

[King_Robbo]

Hi,

I've had Grimley from Essendon on my bench all year coping donut after donut..

Is it worth wasting a trade and only making $6k and trading in Phillios from
Collingwood to get an extra playing emergency ???

I currently have 7 trades remaining with only Kerridge, Hall and Libba to upgrade but there just comfort trades..

Please vote asap

I think it's a wasted trade. You need to bring in Phillips but surely you have better options? I'd just cop the donut otherwise.
Another way to look at it is for loophole purposes.
I've had Wyatt from collingwood all year knowing that he wouldn't play. He's given me great loop hole coverage in which I've gained at least 200 pts from taking the VC score. I think you should look at it that way, if you're able to keep grimley and loop hole him for his donuts as the season goes on, defiantly keep

[Mark]

Haven't voted as while I think it is actually a good trade, with only 7 trades left it may be one you regret down the track, those trades are going to be golden later on

That's my drama..

In the hand I get another playing rookie who will make 60k plus profit this week and I have got a complete tam now....

And the other hand with only 6 trades remaining after (if) I do this trade it could come back to make me cry...

Arhhh bloody supercoach

[Mark]

Hi,

I've had Grimley from Essendon on my bench all year coping donut after donut..

Is it worth wasting a trade and only making $6k and trading in Phillios from
Collingwood to get an extra playing emergency ???

I currently have 7 trades remaining with only Kerridge, Hall and Libba to upgrade but there just comfort trades..

Please vote asap

I think it's a wasted trade. You need to bring in Phillips but surely you have better options? I'd just cop the donut otherwise.
Another way to look at it is for loophole purposes.
I've had Wyatt from collingwood all year knowing that he wouldn't play. He's given me great loop hole coverage in which I've gained at least 200 pts from taking the VC score. I think you should look at it that way, if you're able to keep grimley and loop hole him for his donuts as the season goes on, defiantly keep

Ive got Loesch as my floating donut loophole player.

Other options to get phillips is Brown from Essendon in forwards.. or Trengrove, Jansen or Stewart in mids, and they all have $$ to make

[King_Robbo]

Hi,

I've had Grimley from Essendon on my bench all year coping donut after donut..

Is it worth wasting a trade and only making $6k and trading in Phillios from
Collingwood to get an extra playing emergency ???

I currently have 7 trades remaining with only Kerridge, Hall and Libba to upgrade but there just comfort trades..

Please vote asap

I think it's a wasted trade. You need to bring in Phillips but surely you have better options? I'd just cop the donut otherwise.
Another way to look at it is for loophole purposes.
I've had Wyatt from collingwood all year knowing that he wouldn't play. He's given me great loop hole coverage in which I've gained at least 200 pts from taking the VC score. I think you should look at it that way, if you're able to keep grimley and loop hole him for his donuts as the season goes on, defiantly keep

Ive got Loesch as my floating donut loophole player.

Other options to get phillips is Brown from Essendon in forwards.. or Trengrove, Jansen or Stewart in mids, and they all have $$ to make

There's your answer mate. Stewart won't be playing anytime soon so I'd go Stewart to Philips to get the 18 on field.

In saying that Brown to Phillips would give you the extra cash and let's be honest Brown may only score 30 odd in this game so could be worth it lol

[HotTiges]

Is a macpherson to phillips a waste of a trade??opens up dpp link with hall at f7 to m9..

[Judd Magic]

Is a macpherson to phillips a waste of a trade??opens up dpp link with hall at f7 to m9..

I'd do that trade mate.

[HotTiges]

Is a macpherson to phillips a waste of a trade??opens up dpp link with hall at f7 to m9..

I'd do that trade mate.

would allow me to grab Boyd instead of a defender under 500k but keep Kedge for a week longer

[Mark]

Do ppl think Stewart from Hawks will get another game ?

Might trade in Phillips for him now.. Also opens DDP with my forwards

[Judd Magic]

Is a macpherson to phillips a waste of a trade??opens up dpp link with hall at f7 to m9..

I'd do that trade mate.

would allow me to grab Boyd instead of a defender under 500k but keep Kedge for a week longer

When you add all that to the equation then it becomes a no brainer for me.

[JBs-Hawks]

Stewart should sporadically get games

[Raiden]

Is a macpherson to phillips a waste of a trade??opens up dpp link with hall at f7 to m9..

I'm also doing this trade.

[mark44]

I've traded in silvagni for mcarthy to save 1 of 2 donuts lol