Selwood vs Rocky

[Grazz]

I'd take Neale in a heartbeat, but he would cost me two trades. I can get Rocky, Selwood, or Gray with one. Still can't make up my mind which one though. :P

Asparagus summed it up pretty well, all 3 are risky for one reason or another form/health. Could of gone with any of them but i'm saving me pennys and grabbing Neale next week then maybe Rocky after his bye if he's still healthy will cost me more but I can't risk loosing him again with another hamstring breaking. To many trades burnt through injury already. :(

[no eye deer]

I'd take Neale in a heartbeat, but he would cost me two trades. I can get Rocky, Selwood, or Gray with one. Still can't make up my mind which one though. :P

Rocky- injury risk- high
Gray- rest/surgery once finals out of reach- medium
Selwood- neither of these concerns

I have both jelwood and gray and would def go jelwood.

Hmm, I've been all over Gray all week, but just had a look at the Cats last four games (SC finals). Then again Port could be fighting hard to make the finals and they have a couple of easy games late as well, plus a Showdown so Gray might go just as well. Who knows?

No doubt I'll decide just before the Port game tomorrow! ::)

[Peter]

Am grinning - got both

[Asparagus]

I'd take Neale in a heartbeat, but he would cost me two trades. I can get Rocky, Selwood, or Gray with one. Still can't make up my mind which one though. :P

Asparagus summed it up pretty well, all 3 are risky for one reason or another form/health. Could of gone with any of them but i'm saving me pennys and grabbing Neale next week then maybe Rocky after his bye if he's still healthy will cost me more but I can't risk loosing him again with another hamstring breaking. To many trades burnt through injury already. :(

Going to hold off getting Neale now Grazz?
After yesterdays poor score in the 50's he may be worth getting after his bye...

[ronl]

Well, if it came down to sheer guts, which would you rather have?  Come on, truthfully.

[Grazz]

I'd take Neale in a heartbeat, but he would cost me two trades. I can get Rocky, Selwood, or Gray with one. Still can't make up my mind which one though. :P

Asparagus summed it up pretty well, all 3 are risky for one reason or another form/health. Could of gone with any of them but i'm saving me pennys and grabbing Neale next week then maybe Rocky after his bye if he's still healthy will cost me more but I can't risk loosing him again with another hamstring breaking. To many trades burnt through injury already. :(

Going to hold off getting Neale now Grazz?
After yesterdays poor score in the 50's he may be worth getting after his bye...

Yes mate, will save a fair chunk of cash waiting till after his bye. I'll look elsewhere for this weeks trade and probably sideways to Neale for bugger all. Glad I couldn't afford him last week now.