rate my side out of 10 please, comments appreciated

[spedling]

backs: goddard, enright, grimes, hodge, shaw, malceski, waters (maguire, silvani)
centers: swan, bartel, pendlebury, masten, martin, barlow (banner, bastinac)
rucks: tippet, hille (warnock, grimley)
forwards: riewoldt, okeefe, pavlich, higgins, ziebell, dangerfield, rockliff (gumbleton, podsiadly)

cheers

[elephants]

okay here we go...

back
goddard is a great pick. he didnt fit into my team structure or my salary cap but will be reliable and consisten. enright very similar. will be reliable and consistent and hasnt missed a game in years. grimes is an interesting pick. i think there are better options at his price and the second year blues dont help his case but its up to you. hodge and shaw are defnites both spending more time in the midfield meaning more dt points. malc coming back from a bid knee injury has looked awesome so far me and you are hoping he will keep it up. waters also back from serious injury but when he gets firing he will be awesome.

mids
swan GUN GUN and GUN he will be a lock in captain for you never injured and always getting hundreds good pick if you can afford him. bartel. now hes my captain along with riewoldt consistent and a good back up for swan. pendles back afetr a knee injury and from all reports firing on all cylinders good pick. masten is good he will shoot up in value and could be a potentioal keeper. martin and barlow best rookies in the comp at the moment get them and lock the in.

rucks.
tippet should up his value but he will play full forward so less of the ball is obvious. hille a good pick will rise in value there too.

forwards
riewoldt is a no brainer. got to have him at some stage to win dt and why not have him from the start? ROK to get more mid time and i had him as captain when he got his famous 173 last year get him in too. pav gor once has not made my side. didnt like the way freo delivered the ball inside 50 made it almost impossible for pav to get a touch and with a deeloping midfield i cant see that changing too soon. higgins is very injury prone. hes a gun but i think your btter off getting gia who has had a stellar pre season and is looking fitter then ever. again however completley your descision.ziebell a good rookie from last year. i ussually never get the second year players but he is my exception move to the midfield and should be an awesome player and dter. dangers also can only rise in value the only way is up for this dangermmouse. in my opinion the only thing i dislike about your team is the fact you have rockliffe starting and i think he i better off on the bench..

hope this helps can you plaese rate my team

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,10294.0.html

thanks mate