Last premium defender poll

[no eye deer]

Simple poll. Who should I grab to finish my defense?

Docherty-  $575,700 BE 135.
Bye completed. Had my heart set on him for a while for my last upgrade, but his price kept rising. Is he worth the extra 50k? In awesome form, can he keep going?

Simmo- $528,700 BE 103.
Bye completed. Simmo is Simmo, super consistent, you know what your getting, but do I need someone who can go larger, considering the line isn't that strong?

Bartel-$522,600 BE 94
Bye Round 15. Love the look of him at the moment. Could cause me a donut this week, but going for league and I'm  top four in my cash leagues, so a loss wouldn't be the end of the world. Chance of resting? The Cats have an easy run in SC finals, so resting a possibility.

For the record, my defense is- Shaw, ???, Boyd, Laird, McVeigh, Z Williams (Collins, Brand)

I went cheap with McVeigh and Williams, which is going ok if McVeigh can keep it up. Hence the need to gain some points with this upgrade.

Not really considering others at this stage.

Cheers in advance for votes/advice.

[colmullet]

Id take a player who has already played the bye over one who has it yet to come

[Jimmykidd]

Docherty. Worth every cent

[jumbo]

The way Docherty is scoring. Too good to pass up. To lethal not to have if you're opponent has him... If you can afford it. Go there!

I have Shaw, Docherty, Simpson, Bartel and need to work out my final two prem defenders.

Would you get Rance and Laird and be done. Or get just get one of Rance/Laird and wait for Boyd? Who's best out of Rance and Laird with their fixtures?