Bartel or Barlow?

[Thewizz71]

If you were to offload one of these guys this week, who would it be and why?
Cheers.

[Holz]

Bartel has played the hawks and scored 88

then in a very uncharacteristic loss 61 in a game where he had 1 mark and 1 tackle. just for reference he usually get 6 marks and 4 tackles a game.

by no means do you trade him.

this is a guy who averaged 96 unsubbed last year and this is his lowest average since SC was started in 2005.

he also has Brisbane Dees as his next two opponents and i think you would say geelong would be strong favorites to win.

[crowls]

Bartel has played the hawks and scored 88

then in a very uncharacteristic loss 61 in a game where he had 1 mark and 1 tackle. just for reference he usually get 6 marks and 4 tackles a game.

by no means do you trade him.

this is a guy who averaged 96 unsubbed last year and this is his lowest average since SC was started in 2005.

he also has Brisbane Dees as his next two opponents and i think you would say geelong would be strong favorites to win.

Answered question I put to Eagles who sees Bartel only getting 70 avg.   ATM holding Bartel, Barlow, Rocky and Rich.     Most likely to trade this week would be Barlow as Ross cannot be relied upon to put him in Mids especially as they are changing their game plan.  ( lots of teething issues at the moment)

[bottlemart]

Neither. 

Do you have Rockliffe, if so he would be my vote to get the chop, out for 2 weeks and a BE of 184, and very injury prone.

[Thewizz71]

Neither. 

Do you have Rockliffe, if so he would be my vote to get the chop, out for 2 weeks and a BE of 184, and very injury prone.

Currently holding both.
Looking at Rocky -> Parker and Gresh -> Bennedy (only rook I don't have and feel I should ).

[bottlemart]

Neither. 

Do you have Rockliffe, if so he would be my vote to get the chop, out for 2 weeks and a BE of 184, and very injury prone.

Currently holding both.
Looking at Rocky -> Parker and Gresh -> Bennedy (only rook I don't have and feel I should ).

Yes good move.

[Ricochet]

Neither. 

Do you have Rockliffe, if so he would be my vote to get the chop, out for 2 weeks and a BE of 184, and very injury prone.

Currently holding both.
Looking at Rocky -> Parker and Gresh -> Bennedy (only rook I don't have and feel I should ).

Yes good move.

Agree, I like both those trades mate

[ants]

im giving them both 1 more week!

[RaisyDaisy]

im giving them both 1 more week!

[Ringo]

im giving them both 1 more week!

With Rocky to deal with and the need to get Papley in both saved from the guillotine for another week.