Vossys SC dairy

[fanTCfool]

Might I also point out that the title of the thread includes 'Have a crack at my side'

[mattttwillll]

Drop either Menadue or Kennedy to a rookie priced and upgrade either Kolo or Bartel to whoever really. overall solid team!

[Capper]

Menadue and Kennedy are pretty much rookie priced though

[crowls]

I opened up this link and a few more teams in the Rate my Team section and they were all the same. Except the others didn't have Mathieson because he is injured.

All these teams have no Rocky?

Oh crap you're right my apologises. The other teams are much better.

Ditch KK to another premo, you can probably free up cash by doing Priddis to Rocky.

I'm not sure what you're looking for, you've ranked in the top 1% for 3 straight years, you know exactly what you're doing and you posted a stock standard team?

EDIT* before you all think I'm being harsh, this guy has pages and pages of him asking questions on FF and receiving help and there isn't a post giving back to the community at all. He's done so well for three years, you'd think he could help some other people some time?

You're a hero buddy. Just looking on some feedback on my first team of the year, flog.

I did give you feedback, regarding KK and rocky.

If it wasn't clear I will give you more feedback. How about looking at other peoples teams and giving them feedback before expecting everyone to help you?

Noted that he/she calls it a dairy rather diary - perhaps just a tugger, or is that inappropriate?

Just got told to put that as my name instead of making new post not much to it tbh will try to keep it updated this year but I get busy during the year. However I was ranked top 1% last three years.

I'm sure people would love to hear your advice, especially as you have finished in the top 1% for the last 3 years.

Not trying to sound like a d*ckhead or anything but do i really have to, I'm just looking at getting advice on my team and not much else sorry.

Well you may be failing with that attempt for now....

Put it this way, if everyone did what you're suggesting the forum ceases to exist, it needs to be a two way street.

Pretty selfish attitude Vossy.    SC and forum is only as good as it is through contributions and feedback from others.   Dont know about you, but I have learnt a lot on this forum and it is the source I keep coming back too each season.      If you want to run a journal for your team changes and updates.  Great.  Thats what I do as I find it easier to track than on my own computer.    Who knows maybe your life is full and overflowing and you cannot find the energy to contribute.    Forum will still be here when you do.

[Ringo]

As most have said here it is a two way street. Finishing top 1% I am sure most would appreciate your comments you can even pick your marks as I do and I have yet to crack to the Top 2000.

Comments on your team Matthieson is out for 4/6 weeks.
One of the very few teams I have seen without Pendles and Rocky and no doubt you have your reasons. Just think you have gone too heavy with M4 - M8 as matt has said Rocky/Pendles with a rookie will score more for you.

[crowls]

Defs[/size]: [/size]H. Shaw, K. Kolodjashnij, J. Bartel, J Weitering, M. Dea, M. Brown[/font] (M. Adams, M. Hartley)[/size]Mids: N. Fyfe, P. Dangerfield, G. Ablett, M. Priddis, T. Libartore, B. Crouch, C. Mills, J. Greesham (C. Menadue, R. Mathieson, R. Davis)[/size]Rucks: T. Goldstein, N. Naitanui (S. Grimley) [/size]Fwds: D. Martin, M. Barlow, L. Franklin, D. Wells, B. Kennedy, S. Kerridge (L. McCarthy, A. Mcdonald Tipungwuti)[/size]

[/size]
strong backline with 3 keeps and weit and day[/size]
good mids though weaker than most other teams on here.  must be a reason you have gone for stronger back and fwds and reduced mids.    will give you an advantage if it pays off.[/size]
Franklin has been in and out of my team.  Not sure if he will last the year and if his reliability for scoring will stack up.   Prefer robbo or s gray maybe greene.[/size]
Cheers  your comments on my team would be appreciated[/size]

[greco272]

First go at 2016 been very busy.

Defs: H. Shaw, K. Kolodjashnij, J. Bartel, J Weitering, M. Dea, M. Brown (M. Adams, M. Hartley)

Mids: N. Fyfe, P. Dangerfield, G. Ablett, M. Priddis, T. Libartore, B. Crouch, C. Mills, J. Greesham (C. Menadue, R. Mathieson, R. Davis)

Rucks: T. Goldstein, N. Naitanui (S. Grimley)

Fwds: D. Martin, M. Barlow, L. Franklin, D. Wells, B. Kennedy, S. Kerridge (L. McCarthy, A. Mcdonald Tipungwuti)

Not much cash to play with

Please give any feed back possible!

I'll just say straight up, you obviously know what's going on posting this team up. Structure is as sound as they come.

Backs - Perfect, really strong line up having Dea at D5, may have overspent if someone like Broad can get a consistent game.

Mids - Mathieson has to go (i'm sure you know) Crouch to me seems to expensive, i know he is good but get oliver instead and use the 100k to upgrade elsewhere. No PENDELS, most consistent SC player of all time!! Your loss i guess.

Rucks - set and forget

Fwds - Franklin NO, always lets you down, use the 100k from couch downgrade to upgrade franklin to ZORKO, DALH, MONTY

Overall this team will smoke more teams i've seen, very sound and structured. Just wait on rookies to finalise. Great Job!

[AaronKirk]

There is not much that can go wrong with your side man.

Personally I think there is a fair bit or risk with KK. What will his role be? Will he continue to get more mid time? If not will he get the same amount of ball of half back he got last year if Malceski and McKenzie improve?

IMO there are safer options that can be considered depending on your cash situation like Houli, Simpson and Birchall.

The other concern is M10, M11. Mathieson obviously will miss and Davis still needs to be promoted to the senior list but is a good chance with the Swallow LTI. When Round 1 teams come out next week we will have a better idea.

I don't have the same concerns with the buddy pick, not in my side but he is fighting fit and will probably roam up the ground a bit more as witnessed in the NAB challenge which could well improve his scores.

I like the Priddis pick in the mids.

[Capper]

There is not much that can go wrong with your side man.

Personally I think there is a fair bit or risk with KK. What will his role be? Will he continue to get more mid time? If not will he get the same amount of ball of half back he got last year if Malceski and McKenzie improve?

Agree on that comment, especially with Rosa now at GC.

Are GC getting to many ball disposers in the back field rather then key defenders?

Also not sold on Grimley at R3 averaged 36 at 75% game time.

Davis and McDonald-Tipa need to be elevated.

[vossy12]

New updated team, please have a look and with the rookies I'm just sitting tight and waiting for round 1 teams.
$26,900 left

[Glenmaggie]

For me this looks like a very strong team, I like it a lot. I think you are one premo mid short. But Libba and Crouch have great upside. I would like to see Hall in your side over gray as I think he will definitely score more. But really, you could go in to round one happily with this side

[vossy12]

For me this looks like a very strong team, I like it a lot. I think you are one premo mid short. But Libba and Crouch have great upside. I would like to see Hall in your side over gray as I think he will definitely score more. But really, you could go in to round one happily with this side

Im not sold on Hall as everyone else it, Gray is a personal fav of mine and i think he will have an amazing year so I'm holding on him, trying to work out a way to get crouch to a prem but not working as far, just trying to hold tight till teams are named