Davey+100k vs Chapman

Started by TigerFever, March 14, 2009, 10:41:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Davey+100k vs Chapman

Davey and 100k
0 (0%)
Chapman
8 (88.9%)
Other ( Please State )
1 (11.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

TigerFever

What is a better pick??
Davey and 100k
or
Chapman

Marcus

I prefer Pavlich.
But then again I had Chapman last year so you would understand why I'm not going back there again.

Bo

Chapman. Dont fill yer team with non elites when you have the option to pick one up. a 99 average from 17 games isn't good enough for you marcus ? Oh well.

Marcus

If Supercoach were about picking players that are good I'd need an infinite salary cap and more than 30 slots.
Bo I said I PREFER Pavlich. Then I stated my reasoning. I'm entitled to my opinion and I certainly do not appreciate your sarcasm.

TigerFever

Pav is 60k more. I ment who is a better pick under 532k.

Marcus

Under 532k. Hmmm. I'd go with Porplyzia if you are still looking at mid or premium players. I love the porpoise and expect him to become a premium this season. That being said his preseason has been basically non-existent so I wouldn't lock him in until he makes Rd. 1 team sheet.
He is a great footballer and showed that last year with a 4 goal effort in the 3rd quarter of an even game to win Adelaide that game.
He was scoring 90+ average last year until his shoulder problems and even then played through it to deliver good games. Watch him bloom.

brownmans muffins


Bo

Porplyzia ? he's injured... best not to put injured dudes in yer team IMO. Best to put elite geelong midfield/forwards like chappy in yer team IMO.... IMO

Marcus

Do you even read the posts Bo?
I wrote 'That being said his preseason has been basically non-existent so I wouldn't lock him in until he makes Rd. 1 team sheet.'
He is NO LONGER INJURED. He is recovering from surgery and is a chance at Round 1.
Bo please don't target my comments with ridiculous sarcastic comments because I wouldn't like to start a personal argument with anyone on this site.

jimmyha

Had Porps from the start last year and he was a star until his shoulders. If i see him on the team sheets for Rd 1 he is definately in

Bo

Just the question was posed is all. I find it hard to see why you'd replace an elite midfielder in the best team in the league, who scored 132 last week, with an injury recovering - preseason interrupted midfielder who only scored over 100 on 5 occasions last year.

Im not saying porplyzia isn't good, but telling people to put him in their team is bordering on deliberate misinformation. Sure he might end up playing well, but its still a huge risk.