Pittard or Smith?

Started by kevinjames35, June 18, 2015, 12:55:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

kevinjames35

With Jasper moving up to a wing I think he is a massive chance to average 90-95 from here on, Brodie Smith has more runs on the board but no overly confident in selecting him. Both are very cheap and looking at bringing one in for Jake Lever after next week.
Would love some opinions!

DoctorRush

Would love to see some evidence of his new "role" on the wing.
How many times have we been sucked in by coaches and fellow players saying how someone is "changing roles" only to see them play the same role as always.

I will definitely keep an eye on him this week and maybe have a look after round 13.

AaronKirk

After watching Pittard last week against the cats there would be no way at all I would consider him.

But it was only 1 bad game I guess.

elephants

Yeah interesting, wouldn't mind some more proof of this on the wing business by Pittard

HotTiges

Quote from: elephants on June 18, 2015, 02:19:10 PM
Yeah interesting, wouldn't mind some more proof of this on the wing business by Pittard
Hartlett mentioned it in an interview..Had Pittard for 5 weeks for scores of  59, 71, 63, 61, 95 and 80..had scored 3 tons in a row previously..i wouldn't go changing any trades to bring him although he has scored better these last 2 weeks..

HotTiges

We won't stop taking the game on, says Jasper: http://t.co/RPUBaedrF7 #weareportadelaide

jfitty

Pittard has shown a bit the last few weeks, was on 2 at quarter time in the game against Geelong and ended up on 80.

If I was picking between the 2 it would be Smith, but Pittard's form does seem to be improving.

honza

Quote from: DoctorRush on June 18, 2015, 01:02:55 PM
Would love to see some evidence of his new "role" on the wing.
How many times have we been sucked in by coaches and fellow players saying how someone is "changing roles" only to see them play the same role as always.

Atley
Watts