Which defender

[bwsh]

Shaw Gibson Newnes Oxley Saad Pearce.

Happy to keep pearce there for 2-3 weeks.

Offloading saad, which defender do you reckon?

[jcuz001]

Hodge without a doubt

[Grazz]

Hodge the standout for me but some value in the others named aswell.

[GCSkiwi]

I would rank them Hodge>>Simmo>>>>>TMac=Houli

[Ringo]

I would rank the same as GC Hodge by a long way from Simpson with Mac and Houli virtually equal.

[Holden the ball]

i have tmac simpson and hodge
if i need a defender who already had his bye would houli be the best option

[Woppa15]

Is Hodge worth the extra $64k over Houli for an extra 6 points avg?

[Ringo]

i have tmac simpson and hodge
if i need a defender who already had his bye would houli be the best option

The only other worth considering would be Rory Laird.

[Raiden]

Is Hodge worth the extra $64k over Houli for an extra 6 points avg?

I'm starting to think Houli is better value atm.

[Gambino]

Bob Murphy at $460k is good value too

[Woppa15]

I actually think TMac at $486k/106avg and Houli at $480k/103avg are far better value than Hodge at $544k/109avg.

I think the extra $60k can be far better used elsewhere. I'm personally not keen on paying top dollar for defenders, they're never as consistent as the other positions on the ground......