What's better?

[Cruiseon]

Greetings all, been awhile, quite a while but nothing like a victory over Carlton to get the old fires burning.

Sitting in the crowd on Friday watching Mick get humiliated, Carlton fans turning on their own insipid club and discussions turning to whether they should trade Murphy or Gibbs first, I thought as Collingwood supporters, hey that's our job to insult Carlton and they are insourcing it.

And I thought I'd ask, when you upset an overrated Essendon on ANZAC Day or humiliate Mick and Carlton on their big night, which is best and what other things compare?

[Cambo]

 ;D ;D ;D

Now thats a tough call.  Both ogh so sweet for different reasons.
Taking the wind out of Essendons sails on the big day is always a sweet moment  ;D
Smashing the Blues is great anytime, but they are almost as bad as Brisbane at the moment  :P

So in the grand scheme of things the Anzac Day win means a bit more......

Would be great if the boys can make finals this year, even if just to shut up all clowns that had them written off at the start of the season......

[T Dog]

Better?  nothing   ;D

[Spite]

Was at both games and the Carlton game had me grinning a little bit more. Absolutely loved it. Pies fans were getting right into it like I haven't seen in quite a long time. They were singing the Pies song at about the 10 min mark of the last quarter on repeat, until all the Blues supporters started leaving.

Seeing Murphy so soft so many times during the contest and Gibbs racking up a huge 14 possessions was cherries on top.

GO WOODS!