Schade vs Amon vs Stretch vs Dick

Started by Cunno, May 15, 2015, 12:17:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cunno

Have been left to consider these 3 as potential downgrade targets this week.

All bar Schade are probably a vest risk, so Schade is getting the nod for the moment i reckon.
Although picking a FB goes against all of my better judgement, I am a desperate man.

Anybody else in a similar position?

Jroo

Yep, I'm looking at the same lot although add in Ah Chee too, could be a spot up for grabs when Cornes retires.

Capper

Schade will see a lot of the ball though. Hopefully it doesnt go over his head all the time

Ricochet

I'm going MDick at this stage. Just becuase he's a mid/def so a little more flexibility

He should get a good run at Carlton as well

timmyparso

Quote from: JROO8 on May 15, 2015, 12:22:22 PM
Yep, I'm looking at the same lot although add in Ah Chee too, could be a spot up for grabs when Cornes retires.

Be aware that Wines will be back very soon but Ah Chee should be ahead of Amon at the moment at Port.

Cunno

Quote from: Ricochet on May 15, 2015, 12:30:46 PM
I'm going MDick at this stage. Just becuase he's a mid/def so a little more flexibility

He should get a good run at Carlton as well

B/E of 40 though... Might jump on next week if he gets a decent run

chief007

Dicks last 2 in the vfl were 65 and 54 hadn't been smashing it and with a be of 40 he will need a decent score to start making decent money so he could be worth watching how he goes this week, Schade is prob the pick of the bunch will get a few games with the Suns injury woes but u wldnt reckon he would pump out Massive scorers

MGK1

As a Carlton supporter Dick needs to do well and some to give him a regular gig in the senior side, I would not trade him in. Schade is the way to go i think