The Good, The Bad and The Ugly - Round 1

[batt]

1935.  Good for 75k ranking 8)

Yep I got nuked as well. Can we be friends.

We'll call it the top 37% club.

[dicko_]

2034
Good: Danger, Gray, Swan & McIntosh
Bad: Hibberd, Newnes, Griffen, Cripps, Salem
Ugly: Martin
Trades: Maric > Bellcho and Griffen > Tex (Next week Cockatoo > Lewis)
I have opted with a structural change. I would love your thoughts on this trade as i see the rucks scoring as a potential game changer due to the amt of money Sauce and Mummy will leak. Cheers

Wouldn't be jumping on Tex after just one game. If you were to pick anyone in the forward line, it should really be blokes who play midfield most of the time, and will get consistently solid scores. However getting off high end rucks is not the worst idea.

Good: McIntosh, Houli, Lewis, Fyfe, Pendles, Goldstein, Gray, Swan, at least breaking the 2k mark
Bad: Starting Miller on field with Heeney and CEY on bench, and Cripps playing forward for some reason
Ugly: Dusty and Duckwood. Expected slightly more out of them

[sammy123]

Score 2142 rank about 5,,000 odd.

Good: lewis,gibbo,jpk,swan,heeney,vandenberg,mcintosh

Bad: dusty, newnes, miller(was on bench though), cripps,salem

Ugly: nothing really no one got injured or suspended.

Trades none. I don't rage trade rd 1 :)

[GCSkiwi]

Good: JPK, McIntosh, Swan, Heeney, Vandenberg, Adam Saad
Bad: Goddard, Hibberd, Miller
Ugly: No-one really.

Trades: Likely none this week. Missed CEY as I was out and couldn't do it on mobile (dunno why but it wouldn't work) so he may factor in with another week's evidence...

[My Chumps]

shower first round for me.

Good: Hanners the POD, McIntosh, Gray, Fyfe, Beams, Simpson, Buddy not having a stinker in the wet
Bad: Goddard, Salem, Ibbotson
Ugly: Dusty, Selwood's worst score in 2 years and going with motherflowering Dom Sheed instead of Newton/Brayshaw/NVB

Trades: Sheed ---> Newton. Has to be done. Don't go with POD rookies.

[YoungGun]

shower first round for me.

Good: Hanners the POD, McIntosh, Gray, Fyfe, Beams, Simpson, Buddy not having a stinker in the wet
Bad: Goddard, Salem, Ibbotson
Ugly: Dusty, Selwood's worst score in 2 years and going with motherflowering Dom Sheed instead of Newton/Brayshaw/NVB

Trades: Sheed ---> Newton. Has to be done. Don't go with POD rookies.

hopefully sheed gets dropped or is sub so we dont feel bad about burning a rnd 1 trade

[Bully]

shower first round for me.

Good: Hanners the POD, McIntosh, Gray, Fyfe, Beams, Simpson, Buddy not having a stinker in the wet
Bad: Goddard, Salem, Ibbotson
Ugly: Dusty, Selwood's worst score in 2 years and going with motherflowering Dom Sheed instead of Newton/Brayshaw/NVB

Trades: Sheed ---> Newton. Has to be done. Don't go with POD rookies.

Sheed doesn't look ready, I would have no hesitation in trading him out.

[BigMac_93]

Good: Sticking with Ablett, Gibson, R Gray, Pendles, Fyfe, Beams, Vandenberg, A Saad
Bad: Salem, Cripps, Newnes, Not picking K McIntosh
Ugly: Dusty

[frenzy]

good - went Docherty as a breakout, round 1 tick and had McIntosh on the field.

bad - Rocky capt was looking good at half time, before turning pare shaped.

ugly - premos dishing up shower, Dusty, Jelwood


trades;  Looking at Rocky and Cripps/Brayshaw out and B.Smith and Bont in.

[TexR74]

Good: Lewis, Bontempelli,McIntosh
Bad: Griffen, Miller, Goodes
Ugly: Hibberd, Cripps, Salem
Trades: Lycett ==>Walker