Rate my team

[alex123711]

Def: B. Smith, S. Fisher, A. Fasolo, J. Newnes, B. Goodes, N. Brown
Sub: K. McIntosh, A. Saad

Mid: G. Ablett, N. Fyfe, J. Selwood, T. Green, T. Cotchin, D. Rich, N. Van Berlo, N. Krakouer
Sub: N. Cockatoo, I. Heeney, A. Vandenberg

Ruck: M. Luenberger, T. Bellchambers
Sub: T. Read

For: R. Gray, D. Swan, C. wingard, M. Bontempelli, C. Slalem, M. Clark,
Sub: T. Lamb, K. Lambert

[alex123711]

Bump! Not sure about my backs mainly, and maybe going with too many premiums overall, not enough growth?

[Swoozie]

Okay I see a few problems with this team IMO.

Defence I wouldn't start Brodie Smith for that price and would take more of a known quantity in Simpson or Shaw. Also not sold on Fisher. Scored his best when playing as a spare in defence in a good side. Just can't see him averaging too highly even if he stays fit. Maybe get Lumumba for him instead?

Mids stands out immediately with no Ablett or Pendlebury. Need at least one of them. Krakouer will play at some stage but not early so move him on.

Rucks are far too light. I like Bellchambers but Leuenberger is iffy. Coming back from injury and now with the emergence of S.Martin, I can see him playing for forward than ruck.

Forwards are okay but I think with the amount of forward rookies, 3 premiums is the way to go. Wingard down to Hogan should free up some cash to upgrade Leuenberger and maybe one of Green or Cotchin to Ablett or Pendles.

[alex123711]

Thanks, I have ~350k leftover so I just upgraded wines to ablett

[alex123711]

Not that sure about lumumba, why are so many people picking him?

[essendon]

alot of people (including me) are picking him due to backlines being weak already and also because hes at a new club. Its amaxing what being at a new club can do in terms of the role your playing. i reckon hes a solid pick

[Samsturmfels]

6/10