Rockcliff or Pendels?

Started by vtaced, April 01, 2015, 03:57:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

vtaced

Rockcliff or Pendels? I'm just a little worried with Beams and Rich coming into the side..

NickyBoy

To start R1: Pendles
Upgrade target: Rocky.

vtaced

Otherwise I can trade Selwood for Rocky, so prem mids would be:

Rocky, Pendels, Fyfe, Boak, Danger

DaveElNacho

Not many people are starting rocky so he's a good POD. Just have to decide whether you think he'll maintain his average from last year.

shaker

Rocky for me but I'm still in love with what he did last year  :-*

Sideboob Bob

Quote from: NickyBoy on April 01, 2015, 04:00:21 PM
To start R1: Pendles
Upgrade target: Rocky.

Rockliff is more than likely a lock, but pendles reliability makes him a must have IMO.

Quote from: vtaced on April 01, 2015, 04:01:50 PM
Otherwise I can trade Selwood for Rocky, so prem mids would be:

Rocky, Pendels, Fyfe, Boak, Danger

I like this move though. As Dave said rock slightly POD   ;D

juzztheball

Not entirely convinced on either... both proven guns but Rocky = high price tag, BIG change in the Brisbane midfield structure and Pendles... well we all know he's a gun but no Beams to support and Swan is shower, Collingwood won't win as many games... im steering clear and will upgrade to one (or both) eventually

Jroo

Pendles, I see Rocky dropping unfortunately.

Mark

Yeah im not loving either also... think both will drop and Fyfe, Selwood, Kennedy, are better picks.

Ricochet

Rocky for sure. Don't expect him to drop too much, if at all

My Chumps


Holz

You shouldn't even think about it

129 125 127 125. It's simple

ronl

I think Beams will take some points off Rocky, but probably not enough to put you off selecting him.  For me it was either him or Ablett, not enough moola for both of them. I went Ablett.