Top 100 Last Year. PLZ rate. (Rate for Rate)

[Hayden7]

Thoughts Guys, Much Appreciated:

DEF:
B Smith
G Birchall
G Ibbotson
J Geary
B Whitecross
A Saad
Bench:
J Hamling
S Edwards


MIDS:
Luke Parker
N Fyfe
P Dangerfield
D Hannebery
R Griffen
T Mitchell
P Cripps
C Ellis-Yolmen
Bench:
J Anderson
T Miller
B Boekhorst


RUCKS:
T Goldstein
Nic Nat
Bench:
T Read


FORWARDS:
R Gray
L Franklin
D Swan
M Bontempelli
M Clark
C Salem
Bench:
J Hogan
J Loonie

Thanks Again.

[LordSneeze]

Defs: Definetly need to strengthen this line. Birchall is injured so be careful. Ibbotson im not a fan of but does have potential to get 90ish if everything falls into place. Geary is the same as Ibbotson. Whitecross is unlikely to play R1, With Essendon getting cleared Edwards wont play.
Mids: Strong - Very different from everything else I have seen, but really think you need to downgrade one to strengthen your defence.
Rucks - Solid
Fwds - Strong wouldn't be touching that.

[locknload]

Agree with Whitecross. Need to take him out.
Birchall is coming off an injury and possible in doubt for R1.
I would also swap out Geary for Newnes.

Maybe
Downgrade Birchall
Change Whitecross to B Goodes
Remaining Cash change Geary to Newnes? A nice to have option but starting Geary is by no means 'bad'.