Who should i trade for buddy

[dror]

I have 105k in the bank.
I would like to trade buddy & broughton.
Who should i trade the for buddy and who for broughton?
Thinking:
buddy > Beams
Broughton > Birchall

thanks

[thebrock]

Can you list the rest of your fwds and backs. If you don't have him then Pav could also be a good option but beams is an obvious choice.

[dror]

Fwds: Sidebottom, Pav, Danger, Chappy, Westhoff, Stewart D, Casboult (So thinking Beams for Casboult).
Def: Deledio, Godd, Hanley, H. Shaw, Lonergan,S. Shaw, Guthrie (so thinking Birchall for Guthrie).

I have Stanton on the bench but not sure when he is back.

thanks,

[Jroo]

Fwds: Sidebottom, Pav, Danger, Chappy, Westhoff, Stewart D, Casboult (So thinking Beams for Casboult).
Def: Deledio, Godd, Hanley, H. Shaw, Lonergan,S. Shaw, Guthrie (so thinking Birchall for Guthrie).

I have Stanton on the bench but not sure when he is back.

thanks,

Here are a few options from my article http://www.supercoachhq.com/9/post/2012/08/the-rookie-ramp-for-round-20.html

Taylor Walker - $449 100

Walker has a great finals draw with games coming up, and with matches against the Dockers, Lions, Dees and Suns, he should get back to his best form. Walker only in 6.11% of teams will be a great point of difference for your team. After already missing 5 games through suspension he will not get rested.

Michael Johnson - $398 500

As much as we think Zac Dawson is a spud, he is very important to Fremantle’s structure and Michael Johnson’s SuperCoach scores. When Johnson and Dawson both play in the same team Johnson averages 97 but when Dawson is out he only averages 76. This is because McPharlin always gets the opposition teams best forward while Dawson will get the 2nd best and allows Johnson to play loose in defence, but with Dawson out Johnson has had to play on the 2nd best forward which has been hurting his Supercoach score. With Dawson now back in the team Johnson is someone I would look at to bring in at only $398k and a DEF/FWD DPP!

Matt Suckling - $377 200

2012 has been an inconsistent year for Matt Suckling. He has scored over 100 Supercoach points 6 times while also scoring under 50 points 3 times. If you are looking for value, than Suckling’s your man. He has an achievable breakeven of 86 and should bounce back against the Power and Suns in the next 2 weeks.
Adam Goodes - $427 900

Goodes is super cheap and with a score of 116 last week he should get back to his best. With big games coming up against the Magpies, Bulldogs, Hawks and Cats, Goodes will need to be at his best if the Swans want to have a top 2 finish!

[dror]

Great information - Thanks.
What about a replacement for Broughton?