Cloke or Lake?

[Blues4flag]

3 trades left and one of these guys needs to go.

Leaning towards Cloke

[Samm79]

Leaning with you, expect the Grundy/Richards tag team to dominate him this week too.

[kilbluff1985]

need to see your team to give right answer

[Blues4flag]

B: Deledio Goddard Birchall Hanley Johnson Enright Lake (Shaw Spurr)
M:Ablett JPK Swan Pendles Carrazzo Thompson (Gibson Couch)
R: Cox Griffin (Redden Campbell)
F: Buddy Sidey Pav Danger Zorko Martin Cloke (Treloar Smedts)   

[KoopKicka]

B: Deledio Goddard Birchall Hanley Johnson Enright Lake (Shaw Spurr)
M:Ablett JPK Swan Pendles Carrazzo Thompson (Gibson Couch)
R: Cox Griffin (Redden Campbell)
F: Buddy Sidey Pav Danger Zorko Martin Cloke (Treloar Smedts)   

How much cash? Because Carrots probably needs to be DPP'ed to the backs.

[Blues4flag]

I just noticed I can trade Trelaor to Beams after doing Shaw- Browne.

ATM 3 trades and 7,500

[pikla]

need to see your team to give right answer

Why would you need to see his team? Both lake and Cloke are starters, its just a question of which one is shi.tter. simple. Team balance isnt important in SC, just get as many points out onto the field as possible.

BTW I would get rid of Cloke. Only decent score he's had since I can remember was him beating up on little kids. Then grab Stevie J.

[kilbluff1985]

need to see your team to give right answer

Why would you need to see his team? Both lake and Cloke are starters, its just a question of which one is shi.tter. simple. Team balance isnt important in SC, just get as many points out onto the field as possible.

BTW I would get rid of Cloke. Only decent score he's had since I can remember was him beating up on little kids. Then grab Stevie J.

your a tool, because it's good to see other players in def and fwd to see which line is the weakest before making the call

and after seeing his team KoopKicka pointed out if he had the cash subbing Carrazzo into the back line and getting a better mid was the best option so clearly there are benefits to seeing his team

[Samm79]

need to see your team to give right answer

Why would you need to see his team? Both lake and Cloke are starters, its just a question of which one is shi.tter. simple. Team balance isnt important in SC, just get as many points out onto the field as possible.

BTW I would get rid of Cloke. Only decent score he's had since I can remember was him beating up on little kids. Then grab Stevie J.

your a tool, because it's good to see other players in def and fwd to see which line is the weakest before making the call

and after seeing his team KoopKicka pointed out if he had the cash subbing Carrazzo into the back line and getting a better mid was the best option so clearly there are benefits to seeing his team

Fair point. To get the best answer all relevant information needs to be available. Current team, trades left and $$ should be a prerequisite in topics such as this..

[tor01doc]

Checked out this post just to make sure you were asking which one to get RID of not which one to get.

Well done.

Cloke is the one.

[bowyanger]

Not such an easy decision IMO

Cloke is 10 times more than likely to be a match winner than Lake...just needs to clunk a few...especially against the tougher teams, its much easier to be seen as a match winner by kicking only a few goals than the games Carringbush would dominate.

Lake will see a lot of the pill in defence

Cloke will see a lot of the pill in the FWD line

Carringbush would more than likely get a higher % of the SC point pool than Footerscray

Id trade Lake, Put Carrots down back and get a premium mid like Mitchell,  ASwallow, MMurphy etc.

[bluedreamin]

With the doggies season petering out I can't see Lake giving a rat's toss bag in the final few games... certainly looks to me like he has already put the cue in the rack.

[PowerBug]

need to see your team to give right answer

Why would you need to see his team? Both lake and Cloke are starters, its just a question of which one is shi.tter. simple. Team balance isnt important in SC, just get as many points out onto the field as possible.

BTW I would get rid of Cloke. Only decent score he's had since I can remember was him beating up on little kids. Then grab Stevie J.

your a tool, because it's good to see other players in def and fwd to see which line is the weakest before making the call

and after seeing his team KoopKicka pointed out if he had the cash subbing Carrazzo into the back line and getting a better mid was the best option so clearly there are benefits to seeing his team

Fair point. To get the best answer all relevant information needs to be available. Current team, trades left and $$ should be a prerequisite in topics such as this..

Sorry, i disagree slightly. Please read the "What should i post and where thread". It's a sticky somewhere. Read it and you'll probably find something liek this with the full team posted shouldn't be in this thread, instead it should eb in the RMSC thread.

[Samm79]

need to see your team to give right answer

Why would you need to see his team? Both lake and Cloke are starters, its just a question of which one is shi.tter. simple. Team balance isnt important in SC, just get as many points out onto the field as possible.

BTW I would get rid of Cloke. Only decent score he's had since I can remember was him beating up on little kids. Then grab Stevie J.

your a tool, because it's good to see other players in def and fwd to see which line is the weakest before making the call

and after seeing his team KoopKicka pointed out if he had the cash subbing Carrazzo into the back line and getting a better mid was the best option so clearly there are benefits to seeing his team

Fair point. To get the best answer all relevant information needs to be available. Current team, trades left and $$ should be a prerequisite in topics such as this..

Sorry, i disagree slightly. Please read the "What should i post and where thread". It's a sticky somewhere. Read it and you'll probably find something liek this with the full team posted shouldn't be in this thread, instead it should eb in the RMSC thread.

It's funny that you say that, I actually referenced that prior to making that post, thinking there was something there I could reference to further my point... May be there was something there in days gone by, or may be I'm making it up!

While it is very hard to argue with the reference you used PB, I personally don't agree with the rational. The section is trades and players, and we're commenting on a trade. We're not rating a team, so for mine it's in the best place.

What further backs this is point is how many times do people ask for this information before offering their advice? It just makes sense to me..