Ask Jayman

[Jay]

Another round, another friday arvo i spend answering your SC questions

Fire away supercoaches :)

[colmullet]

who to field.....

Mummy Vs Treloar
Dempsey Vs S.Shaw

[Jay]

who to field.....

Mummy Vs Treloar
Dempsey Vs S.Shaw

mummy & dempsey i reckon mate :)

[Blues Blues Blues]

You are probably sick of me asking the same question 10 different ways, BUT how would you trade to improve this team?

I want to trade out Dempsey, full stop. But HOW?

I have just done DEMPSEY > SCOTLAND, BOOTSMA > BELL. My reasoning is Bell is a D8/D9. And iif Scotland is out due to injury, he may get a call up. Logical? Or wishful thinking (prob the latter!)

But is there any other trades you see?

Team (before the trades above)

DEF: Deledio, Goddard, H Shaw, Carrazzo, Enright, Lake, Dempsey (S Shaw, Bootsma)
MID: Ablett, Swan, Pendles, Watson, Thompson, Jelwood (Gibson, Couch)
RUCK: Maric, Mummy (Campbell, Orren)
FWD: Franklin, Dangerfield, Sidebottom, Chapman, Martin, Goodes, Zorko (Porps, Darling)

Would love your thoughts Jayman, I think I am making myself crazy the time I am taking analyzing this!

[Jay]

You are probably sick of me asking the same question 10 different ways, BUT how would you trade to improve this team?

I want to trade out Dempsey, full stop. But HOW?

I have just done DEMPSEY > SCOTLAND, BOOTSMA > BELL. My reasoning is Bell is a D8/D9. And iif Scotland is out due to injury, he may get a call up. Logical? Or wishful thinking (prob the latter!)

But is there any other trades you see?

Team (before the trades above)

DEF: Deledio, Goddard, H Shaw, Carrazzo, Enright, Lake, Dempsey (S Shaw, Bootsma)
MID: Ablett, Swan, Pendles, Watson, Thompson, Jelwood (Gibson, Couch)
RUCK: Maric, Mummy (Campbell, Orren)
FWD: Franklin, Dangerfield, Sidebottom, Chapman, Martin, Goodes, Zorko (Porps, Darling)

Would love your thoughts Jayman, I think I am making myself crazy the time I am taking analyzing this!

i like the trades u suggested mate...id do them :) bit worried about the cash you have on the fwds bench but hey its a good problem to have ;)

[Blues Blues Blues]

You are probably sick of me asking the same question 10 different ways, BUT how would you trade to improve this team?

I want to trade out Dempsey, full stop. But HOW?

I have just done DEMPSEY > SCOTLAND, BOOTSMA > BELL. My reasoning is Bell is a D8/D9. And iif Scotland is out due to injury, he may get a call up. Logical? Or wishful thinking (prob the latter!)

But is there any other trades you see?

Team (before the trades above)

DEF: Deledio, Goddard, H Shaw, Carrazzo, Enright, Lake, Dempsey (S Shaw, Bootsma)
MID: Ablett, Swan, Pendles, Watson, Thompson, Jelwood (Gibson, Couch)
RUCK: Maric, Mummy (Campbell, Orren)
FWD: Franklin, Dangerfield, Sidebottom, Chapman, Martin, Goodes, Zorko (Porps, Darling)

Would love your thoughts Jayman, I think I am making myself crazy the time I am taking analyzing this!

i like the trades u suggested mate...id do them :) bit worried about the cash you have on the fwds bench but hey its a good problem to have ;)

Thanks Jayman. My fwd bench is heavy, but I have a lot of fwd/mids so effectively they offer me coverage to midfield too. ie if Thompson gets rested against GCS in grand final, I can swing one of them to MIDS in place of Couch, and bring Porps or Darling on field.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Another quick one, if you could afford any premium defender, who would you bring in?

Scotland? Waters? Birchall? Other?

[Jay]

Another quick one, if you could afford any premium defender, who would you bring in?

Scotland? Waters? Birchall? Other?

Scotland just

[Blues Blues Blues]

Another quick one, if you could afford any premium defender, who would you bring in?

Scotland? Waters? Birchall? Other?

Scotland just

Cheers mate

[Hazza09]

Hey Jayman

Treloar or Cloke for fwd7 this week?

[Jay]

Hey Jayman

Treloar or Cloke for fwd7 this week?

cloke :)

[bensl]

s.shaw v ellis D7?

[Jay]

s.shaw v ellis D7?

shaw

[jamesalex]

Get pendles this week or not? 4 trades left, don't need to win this week.

[melowen204]

Is my team good enough to go into finals with.

D'lids, Scotland, Goddard, Birchall, H Shaw, Lake, Spur (s Shaw, Paine)

Watson, Gaj, Pendles, Boyd, NDS, Priddis (magner, Sexton)

Nicnat, Giles (Orren, Campbell)

Danger, Pav, Beams, Sidey, Dahlhaus, Martin, Porps (Smedts, Couch)

Have 5 trades left.  Am thinking Dahlhaus to Buddy in a week or two.

Will Spur/Shaw be ok as D7/8?

Maybe Giles aswell.

Should i make a money trade this week or leave as is. Should win all leagues.