2019 Rookies

[RaisyDaisy]

Ryan Gardner is playing this weekend

Reckon I might go early and jump on this week

I need a fwd rookie and Young/Fort are the only options otherwise. Fort bye is horrible for me and Young was horrible on the weekend and could get dropped

For the Dogs to recruit this guy and bring him straight in speaks volumes - I'll take the risk and go early

[sammy123]

Next week im grabbing bewley then the week after i will grab gardner

[enzedder]

Ryan Gardner is playing this weekend

102k fwd rookie on the bubble rd14 could be the most traded in person in history...

Corbett to Gardner :) Hopefully.

[Dmoney$]

Is it too big of a risk to already bring Gardner in if it means I can afford to bring in Whitfield this week?
I know it’s hard to say but what’s Gardner’s JS looking like list wise (who could take his spot)

[sammy123]

Is it too big of a risk to already bring Gardner in if it means I can afford to bring in Whitfield this week?
I know it’s hard to say but what’s Gardner’s JS looking like list wise (who could take his spot)

Josh schahe or however you spell it

[MontyJnr]

What are Oskar Baker’s chances of actually holding his spot through the byes? The Dees had Lever, Kolodjashnij, May & Neal-Bullen listed as a test this week, are any of them a risk of taking Baker’s spot?

[crowls]

would think lever kolo and neal-bullen all chances to replace baker

[RaisyDaisy]

What are Oskar Baker’s chances of actually holding his spot through the byes? The Dees had Lever, Kolodjashnij, May & Neal-Bullen listed as a test this week, are any of them a risk of taking Baker’s spot?

Not touching him

Shower scoring, bye and JS

[MontyJnr]

What are Oskar Baker’s chances of actually holding his spot through the byes? The Dees had Lever, Kolodjashnij, May & Neal-Bullen listed as a test this week, are any of them a risk of taking Baker’s spot?

Not touching him

Shower scoring, bye and JS

Is his bye actually that bad for midfielders? He fits on the bench alongside Neale & Oliver, while Hayes can be moved on for Bewley if he’s still not getting games and Bailey Scott might be back playing too.

He has been putting up some decent stats too despite it not translating into SC scores. First game got caught HTB a few times and 2nd game most of his work was done in junk time.

JS is the most pressing issue for mine.

[LaHug]

With Hinge dropped and Young on the extended bench (surely to be dropped for Geary), who else is there if not Baker? I wish I hadn't gone Young a week early but desperately needed to avoid a forward donut and avoid fielding Burgess down back... It doesn't get any better this week with very little cash and holes EVERYWHERE

[LaHug]

With Hinge dropped and Young on the extended bench (surely to be dropped for Geary), who else is there if not Baker? I wish I hadn't gone Young a week early but desperately needed to avoid a forward donut and avoid fielding Burgess down back... It doesn't get any better this week with very little cash and holes EVERYWHERE

[RaisyDaisy]

What are Oskar Baker’s chances of actually holding his spot through the byes? The Dees had Lever, Kolodjashnij, May & Neal-Bullen listed as a test this week, are any of them a risk of taking Baker’s spot?

Not touching him

Shower scoring, bye and JS

Is his bye actually that bad for midfielders? He fits on the bench alongside Neale & Oliver, while Hayes can be moved on for Bewley if he’s still not getting games and Bailey Scott might be back playing too.

He has been putting up some decent stats too despite it not translating into SC scores. First game got caught HTB a few times and 2nd game most of his work was done in junk time.

JS is the most pressing issue for mine.

I've already got Hayes, Scott and Stocker so I can't entertain the idea of adding another questionable mid rookie, and none of those 3 are worth trading to Baker imo

Assuming Hayes and Scott don't return that could be potentially 5 mids out that bye round as well

Bewley is the guy I'm targeting over him - just hoping more downgrade options pop up over the next few weeks because that's the only appeal in Baker that he's a rare bubble boy for now but I'm going to pass and hope others pop up

[MontyJnr]

With Hinge dropped and Young on the extended bench (surely to be dropped for Geary), who else is there if not Baker? I wish I hadn't gone Young a week early but desperately needed to avoid a forward donut and avoid fielding Burgess down back... It doesn't get any better this week with very little cash and holes EVERYWHERE

Ed Phillips could easily be dropped for Geary.

Confirmed starters under 150k: Oskar Baker, Brett Bewley, Ryan Gardner

Extended bench under 150k (finalised 5pm today): Robert Young, Darragh Joyce, Dylan Clarke, Irving Mosquito, Rhylee West, Angus Schumacher

[MontyJnr]

What are Oskar Baker’s chances of actually holding his spot through the byes? The Dees had Lever, Kolodjashnij, May & Neal-Bullen listed as a test this week, are any of them a risk of taking Baker’s spot?

Not touching him

Shower scoring, bye and JS

Is his bye actually that bad for midfielders? He fits on the bench alongside Neale & Oliver, while Hayes can be moved on for Bewley if he’s still not getting games and Bailey Scott might be back playing too.

He has been putting up some decent stats too despite it not translating into SC scores. First game got caught HTB a few times and 2nd game most of his work was done in junk time.

JS is the most pressing issue for mine.

I've already got Hayes, Scott and Stocker so I can't entertain the idea of adding another questionable mid rookie, and none of those 3 are worth trading to Baker imo

Assuming Hayes and Scott don't return that could be potentially 5 mids out that bye round as well

Bewley is the guy I'm targeting over him - just hoping more downgrade options pop up over the next few weeks because that's the only appeal in Baker that he's a rare bubble boy for now but I'm going to pass and hope others pop up

Yeah I have the same weak midfield bench combination and I agree it’s dangerous adding Baker to the mix because it means 1 of these guys becomes your 8th mid which will need to be upgraded to a premium at some stage.

Stocker is looking like the best of a bad bunch in terms of value right now, question is whether he can make enough money over the next 3 weeks before his bye to be upgraded?

[EA100]

Thinking of grabbing Begley as it works in with getting Whitfield, what’s everyone think of his JS? Despite his average pricing.