2019 Rookies

Started by quinny88, November 22, 2018, 10:53:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ringo

Quote from: Carn on May 24, 2019, 08:53:38 AM
Hinge or Young?

Hinge - Lots of handballs but in the guts.
Young - score inflated by 2 goals 2 goal assists
I have gone Young as I need coverage in forwards with both Danger and Moore out.

no eye deer

So, do we think Young is a must have, with the Port one gamers getting dropped? I was going to miss him altogether and get Hinge this week, but wondering if I need both leading into the byes. That’s assuming they hold their spots.

Ringo

Quote from: no eye deer on May 24, 2019, 09:24:36 AM
So, do we think Young is a must have, with the Port one gamers getting dropped? I was going to miss him altogether and get Hinge this week, but wondering if I need both leading into the byes. That’s assuming they hold their spots.
Bailey is gone for 6 weeks so it is Hinges spot to lose. One of Hinge or Answerth will make way when he returns.
Robert Young plays for Saints and is mature aged so would expect him to continue and will be handy through byes as well as making cash. Has the first bye though,

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: no eye deer on May 24, 2019, 09:24:36 AM
So, do we think Young is a must have, with the Port one gamers getting dropped? I was going to miss him altogether and get Hinge this week, but wondering if I need both leading into the byes. That’s assuming they hold their spots.

Hinge, Young and Fort

I'll be grabbing 2 of them, because after they bubble there doesn't appear to anybody else on the horizon

I actually can't get both Young and Fort, so it will be Hinge + Young/Fort but I'm double downing on that next week giving me another week to see them all

If Stocker doesn't make the cut then I'll have to go early one 1, and I'm leaning towards Young just because of his better bye and if Ben Long is his only threat I'm fine with that, reckon he gets a decent crack

no eye deer

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on May 24, 2019, 10:03:01 AM
Quote from: no eye deer on May 24, 2019, 09:24:36 AM
So, do we think Young is a must have, with the Port one gamers getting dropped? I was going to miss him altogether and get Hinge this week, but wondering if I need both leading into the byes. That’s assuming they hold their spots.

Hinge, Young and Fort

I'll be grabbing 2 of them, because after they bubble there doesn't appear to anybody else on the horizon

I actually can't get both Young and Fort, so it will be Hinge + Young/Fort but I'm double downing on that next week giving me another week to see them all

If Stocker doesn't make the cut then I'll have to go early one 1, and I'm leaning towards Young just because of his better bye and if Ben Long is his only threat I'm fine with that, reckon he gets a decent crack

Here’s for the replies fellas. I’m in the same boat, RD, if Setters doesn’t get up, I’ll get Young. Will grab Hinge this week otherwise.

MontyJnr

Mid-season draft next week remember, so there could be a few options that pop up out of that.

Young this week, Hinge next week and I'm sure there will be someone else the week after.

Will pass on Fort, I reckon he'll struggle to hold his spot through the byes.

tommy10

Quote from: no eye deer on May 24, 2019, 09:24:36 AM
So, do we think Young is a must have, with the Port one gamers getting dropped? I was going to miss him altogether and get Hinge this week, but wondering if I need both leading into the byes. That’s assuming they hold their spots.
I'm grabbing both too, but Young this week as I have Drew and Danger out. Hinge next week for Clark/Hayes and grab Whitfield, hopefully.

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: MontyJnr on May 24, 2019, 11:39:16 AM
Mid-season draft next week remember, so there could be a few options that pop up out of that.

Young this week, Hinge next week and I'm sure there will be someone else the week after.

Will pass on Fort, I reckon he'll struggle to hold his spot through the byes.

It's a good opportunity for clubs to top up their lists, but do you think any of them will come straight in play? I'd think the odds are low, but we might get lucky with 1 or 2 eventually

I'm passing on Fort too - just doesn't work for my side at all, but if he does have a huge game this weekend then he has to come in just for the cash injection he'll make

HappyDEZ

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on May 24, 2019, 11:49:18 AM
Quote from: MontyJnr on May 24, 2019, 11:39:16 AM
Mid-season draft next week remember, so there could be a few options that pop up out of that.

Young this week, Hinge next week and I'm sure there will be someone else the week after.

Will pass on Fort, I reckon he'll struggle to hold his spot through the byes.

It's a good opportunity for clubs to top up their lists, but do you think any of them will come straight in play? I'd think the odds are low, but we might get lucky with 1 or 2 eventually

I'm passing on Fort too - just doesn't work for my side at all, but if he does have a huge game this weekend then he has to come in just for the cash injection he'll make
Same. If he goes 80+ again & is named on the bubble I think we have to bring him in & hope he puts together 5 or 6 games in a row. You would think he would easily beat Rata & Buzza in the RUC chop out stakes so it really boils down to him hitting the scoreboard. 3 again would be nice 2 borderline & anything less would see him on very shaky ground.

sammy123

Another big score from fort is hard to ignore. If he can make similiar cash to obrian that would be great

HappyDEZ

Quote from: sammy123 on May 24, 2019, 01:46:45 PM
Another big score from fort is hard to ignore. If he can make similiar cash to obrian that would be great
Just realised he has Gold Coast with no Sam Collins. Baptism of fire for Burgess as a defensive option. Looks like he has Fort or Hawkins with Hombsch getting the other. I suppose it couldn't be any harder than trying to hold down a key forward spot at GC in your first year of AFL. At least he should see a fair chunk of the footy.

batt

Bewley in!  Potentially on the bubble post bye!

Mat0369

Anyone grabbing Marsh on the bubble?

backpocket

Bewely early or oskar baker ? Need some mid coverage

Mat0369

Both feel like bad desperation moves. I'd be swinging my DPP around and see if you can grab anyone else