2019 Rookies

[Bones Bombers]

Collins or Scrimshaw???

[batt]

Looking at going (in order):

B: Collins, Clark, Duursma, Burgess, Hore
M: Walsh, Constable, Drew, Scott, Gibbons
F: Setterfield, Petruccelle, Balta, Parker

[Locinator]

A debate a few will be having in the next hour...

Gibbons vs Hind (named on extended bench)

[RaisyDaisy]

I reckon I might take Scrimshaw over Collins and bank the 40k

[batt]

I reckon I might take Scrimshaw over Collins and bank the 40k

Would be silly to pass up the JS Collins has IMO.

[jfitty]

I reckon I might take Scrimshaw over Collins and bank the 40k

I considered this, but just can't see where I'd use the 40k at this stage.

Thinking of playing it safe with Collins..

[Bones Bombers]

I reckon I might take Scrimshaw over Collins and bank the 40k

Would be silly to pass up the JS Collins has IMO.

We can always start Collins and correction trade down to Scrimshaw if necessary.

[Bones Bombers]

I reckon I might take Scrimshaw over Collins and bank the 40k

I considered this, but just can't see where I'd use the 40k at this stage.

Thinking of playing it safe with Collins..

I only have $2,700 in the bank so if I did it I would keep the money in the bank haha

[Samsturmfels]

pick burgess instead of hore? Whats everyones thoughts on Hore possibly getting dropped for May?

[hawkers65]

Atkins v Gibbons is gonna be an interesting choice

[RaisyDaisy]

Atkins v Gibbons is gonna be an interesting choice

Both for me at M10 and M11

As for Collins vs Scrim, I have my side set nicely and can fit Scrim, would need to make a chance somewhere to fit Collins and don't think I want to

Have Moore fwd too, so have the cover just in case

[hawkers65]

Atkins v Gibbons is gonna be an interesting choice

Both for me at M10 and M11

As for Collins vs Scrim, I have my side set nicely and can fit Scrim, would need to make a chance somewhere to fit Collins and don't think I want to

Have Moore fwd too, so have the cover just in case

Do you not have Scott or one of Butters/Hately?

[RaisyDaisy]

Atkins v Gibbons is gonna be an interesting choice

Both for me at M10 and M11

As for Collins vs Scrim, I have my side set nicely and can fit Scrim, would need to make a chance somewhere to fit Collins and don't think I want to

Have Moore fwd too, so have the cover just in case

Do you not have Scott or one of Butters/Hately?

Walsh M7, then Constable, Scott, Atkins, Gibbons

Need to spend more on def rookies this year, so happy to pass on Butters/Hately

[Locinator]

Atkins v Gibbons is gonna be an interesting choice

Both for me at M10 and M11

Also running both, with Walsh, Butters, Constable on field, Scott on the pine

[LordSneeze]

Atkins v Gibbons is gonna be an interesting choice

Both for me at M10 and M11

Also running both, with Walsh, Butters, Constable on field, Scott on the pine

Sounds like my mid.

Doubt Clarke will get up given tge Essendon extended bench