2019 Rookies

[TomK]

He’s got a lot of work to do (Including conditioning) Alastair Clarkson on Jack Scrimshaw via Twitter.

Never been in my side, wasnt confident he'd play rd1

a 144k placeholder who won’t play is better than a 117k placeholder hore who won’t either ;)

[GoLions]

He’s got a lot of work to do (Including conditioning) Alastair Clarkson on Jack Scrimshaw via Twitter.

Never been in my side, wasnt confident he'd play rd1

a 144k placeholder who won’t play is better than a 117k placeholder hore who won’t either ;)

Stfu you filthy hore

[Nige]

He’s got a lot of work to do (Including conditioning) Alastair Clarkson on Jack Scrimshaw via Twitter.

Never been in my side, wasnt confident he'd play rd1

a 144k placeholder who won’t play is better than a 117k placeholder hore who won’t either ;)

The difference got me Brad Crouch.  8)

[Football Factory]

Filthy Scrimshaw

[quinny88]

So judging by Hardwicks words I wouldn't be going with Balta. Sounds like he's still very raw and has a lot to learn in relation to game plan etc. think I'll pass on him for now

[RaisyDaisy]

So judging by Hardwicks words I wouldn't be going with Balta. Sounds like he's still very raw and has a lot to learn in relation to game plan etc. think I'll pass on him for now

Just saw this too

https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-03-18/teenage-beast-the-closest-thing-to-rance-in-mix-for-tiger-debut

Even if he does debut, based off those comments zero chance I start him now

[frenzy]

So judging by Hardwicks words I wouldn't be going with Balta. Sounds like he's still very raw and has a lot to learn in relation to game plan etc. think I'll pass on him for now

atleast its a thursday game, unlike sunday rookies sitting on extended benches

[quinny88]

So judging by Hardwicks words I wouldn't be going with Balta. Sounds like he's still very raw and has a lot to learn in relation to game plan etc. think I'll pass on him for now

Just saw this too

https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-03-18/teenage-beast-the-closest-thing-to-rance-in-mix-for-tiger-debut

Even if he does debut, based off those comments zero chance I start him now

What do you think of Petrucelles JS?

[RaisyDaisy]

What do you think of Petrucelles JS?

I think it's pretty good tbh

Allen might get a game for us but that's if JJK misses

Petruccelle is taking the LeCras/Cripps role, and from all reports he's in the box seat to get a good crack at it

Very comfortable picking him for a bench spot - wouldn't want to field him every week

[quinny88]

What do you think of Petrucelles JS?

I think it's pretty good tbh

Allen might get a game for us but that's if JJK misses

Petruccelle is taking the LeCras/Cripps role, and from all reports he's in the box seat to get a good crack at it

Very comfortable picking him for a bench spot - wouldn't want to field him every week

Sounds good! Easy replacement for Balta on my bench then

[GoLions]

So judging by Hardwicks words I wouldn't be going with Balta. Sounds like he's still very raw and has a lot to learn in relation to game plan etc. think I'll pass on him for now

atleast its a thursday game, unlike sunday rookies sitting on extended benches

Not exactly, seeing as the issue would be more regarding him playing Rd2 if he's in for Lynch in Rd1.

[frenzy]

So judging by Hardwicks words I wouldn't be going with Balta. Sounds like he's still very raw and has a lot to learn in relation to game plan etc. think I'll pass on him for now

atleast its a thursday game, unlike sunday rookies sitting on extended benches

Not exactly, seeing as the issue would be more regarding him playing Rd2 if he's in for Lynch in Rd1.

yeahbut, lol rookies named and not making the final cut will suck. So I'll do a RD and say even if he's named, I won't pick him and just pick him up on the bubble. He could do a Higgins, not dropped since debut

[kilbluff1985]

ppl starting 2 or 3 defender rookies on field are crazy have seen some teams with this

u want Collins at d5 imo

[HoleMeal]

It would not surprise me at all to see Marsh named for the saints. Hasn't played at the top level since 2016 BUT has been playing a decent grade of footy.
In the month of June, the year he was drafted by the Pies, I remember reading an article he would go in the top 15 kids in the nation.
When he was at the Pies I liked the little I saw in him but he never really got a good go at it.
Hope he grabs this second chance he has been given.

[kilbluff1985]

It would not surprise me at all to see Marsh named for the saints. Hasn't played at the top level since 2016 BUT has been playing a decent grade of footy.
In the month of June, the year he was drafted by the Pies, I remember reading an article he would go in the top 15 kids in the nation.
When he was at the Pies I liked the little I saw in him but he never really got a good go at it.
Hope he grabs this second chance he has been given.

pass, Brown is back round 2