Player X v Player Y

[GraysFan]

Gray + fwd rookie vs Barlow + Hopper

leaning towards the 2nd option at the moment

Depends on the rest of your forwards and mids really. But i would defs start Barlow in the forward line :)

[GraysFan]

Goldy + Omeara vs Lobbe + Pendles

[Big Mac]

Goldy + Omeara vs Lobbe + Pendles

1st option, although i'd be keen to try and find another way to fit in Pendles

[RaisyDaisy]

Wells v Simpkin v Anderson

Assuming all 3 line up rd1 and only one spot is available (F5)

[PICCOLLO]

Wells v Simpkin v Anderson

Assuming all 3 line up rd1 and only one spot is available (F5)

Simpkin>Wells>Anderson

Wells injury history puts him at no.2 for me. Anderson: has he shown enough? Simpkin: Strong VFL showing last year.  An AFL reprieve normally keeps a player focussed for a season as he'll be trying to get another contract.

[dmac07]

Shaw & Docherty vs McVeigh & Rance

[TexR74]

this one's giving me many restless nights

Shiel vs Wines or maybe even cunnington as a POD?

[AaronKirk]

this one's giving me many restless nights

Shiel vs Wines or maybe even cunnington as a POD?

Wines for me.

Port have an excellent draw and he is only going to get better. Also the attention from the opposition will still remain with Gray and Boak.

Shiel may cop more attention after his brilliant early season but is also a valid option

[Bluesman]

Craig bird vs matthew Wright as Friday and potential F6/7 n mud bench cover

[PICCOLLO]

Craig bird vs matthew Wright as Friday and potential F6/7 n mud bench cover

\]

New club so you never know whether he'll fit in or where he'll fit in.  I'm sure most people have their eyes on him but it's very much NAB and wait and see

[timtim]

Darcey Parish or Ryan Crowley

Both will play... Crowley will probably get more games AND I've been hearing (albeit only rumours) that he'll play less of a tagging role and more of a pure MID

Both $202,800... but Crowley has a career average of 62 (tagging). Do we think Parish can beat that?

[Gigantor]

Darcey Parish or Ryan Crowley

Both will play... Crowley will probably get more games AND I've been hearing (albeit only rumours) that he'll play less of a tagging role and more of a pure MID

Both $202,800... but Crowley has a career average of 62 (tagging). Do we think Parish can beat that?

Hmm tough one, I would go neither but if I had to pick one I would go Francis

[Gigantor]

Fyfe vs Danger

(Already have Pendles, GAJ and Rocky)

[Hawker_08]

Fyfe vs Danger

(Already have Pendles, GAJ and Rocky)

Same dimena here. Fyfe if fit I think but I do believe Danger can go 118-120 again this year at the cats. Fyfe will go 125+ if all goes to plan.

One of my own.

EMAC (D4) + Fyfe (M1) + 200-250k mid (M7) + Dahl (F2)

Vs

117 k rook (D5-8) + JPK (M3) + Wines (M6) + Devon Smith (D3)

and Smith vs Zerrett

[hawkboy80]

Fyfe vs Danger

(Already have Pendles, GAJ and Rocky)

Same dimena here. Fyfe if fit I think but I do believe Danger can go 118-120 again this year at the cats. Fyfe will go 125+ if all goes to plan.

One of my own.

EMAC (D4) + Fyfe (M1) + 200-250k mid (M7) + Dahl (F2)

Vs

117 k rook (D5-8) + JPK (M3) + Wines (M6) + Devon Smith (D3)

and Smith vs Zerrett

option 1 if Fyfe is good to go