FanFooty Forum

(At the moment 12/5/10/6 with $14,700 left)

Back: Goddard*, Gibbs*, Deledio*, Gilbert" Adcock, Otten, Jacobs*
(Coad, Toy, Hibberd)
Mid: Swan, Montagna, Boyd, Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Heppel, Atley, Mzungu^)
Ruck: Sandilands, Petrie~
(Lycett, Z.Smith)
Fwd: N.Riewoldt, Didak^, Pavlich^, Rioli, Knights, Prestia^, I.Smith
(Talia", Richardson, T.McDonald~)

" = Defence/Foward MPP
* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^ = Centre/Foward MPP
~= Ruck/Forward MPP

Please post thought out of 10 and what I can improve on

kelly is slow starter, more of an upgrade target.

Alrite then here's my changes

Back: Goddard*, Hodge*, Deledio, Gilbert, Otten, Heppel*, Jacobs
(Mzungu, Toy, Richardson)
Mid: Swan, Judd, Hayes, L.Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Wallis, Krakeour, Lester*)
Ruck: Sandilands, Jolly
(Mcdonald^, Z.Smith)
Fwd: Riewoldt, Didak, Pavlich, Rioli, Knights, Petrie^, Prestia
(Matera, Darling, T.Lynch)

* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^= Ruck/Forward MPP

who the hell are lester & mcdonald?
Judd? Remember the brownlow curse

lester plays 4 brisbane was the best  mid/def, taking advantage of his mpp, and mcdonald plays 4 melbourne best ruck/fwrdd 2 swap with petrie. yeah but juddy's so consistent i dont reckon it will apply 2 him

I highly doubt it will apply to judd. He's in his own league.

In 2004 he won the brownlow and in 2005, according to ff, he averaged 115. I'd only have concerns about having Judd because Carlton have the bye in r 21.

Yeah Judd has a stupid bye, but I think his points are worth the trade.

Quote from: tom_scully on December 10, 2010, 11:03:35 PM
who the hell are lester & mcdonald?
Judd? Remember the brownlow curse

mcdonald more of a chance to get a game

More changes to my side with $18,400 left

Back: Goddard*, Hodge*, Deledio, Kelly*, Otten, Heppel*, M.Watson
(Mzungu, Toy, Richardson)
Mid: Swan, Judd, Montagna, L.Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Atley, Wallis, Krakeour)
Ruck: Sandilands, Jolly
(Mcdonald^, Z.Smith)
Fwd: Riewoldt, Didak, Pavlich, Rioli, Petrie^, Prestia, Lamb
(Matera, Darling, Talia)

* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^= Ruck/Forward MPP

In my opinion your original team was really good, from your original team the only thing i could see that you should change was Lynch out as he will take time to develop as a KPP, and probably won't get games at GC unless Day gets injured

stick with your first team sinclair. perhaps backs is a tad weak. 7 outa 10

Thanks for the comment.

Trying something new with this version
(trying to get as many good rookies but have some good cheapies (Adcock, Otten, Petrie) on the field)

Back: Goddard*, Deledio, Kelly*, Broughton, Adcock, Otten, Heppel*
(Mzungu, Toy, Richardson)
Mid: Swan, Judd, Hodge, L.Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Atley, Wallis, Krakeour)
Ruck: Sandilands, Day
(Mcdonald^, Charman)
Fwd: Riewoldt, Didak, Pavlich, Rioli, Petrie^, Prestia, I.Smith
(Lamb, Matera, Darling)

* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^= Ruck/Forward MPP

I think the rucks are too weak with day starting. How much money do you have left?

$63,800 with the latest team starting. I could maybe move charman out for a cheaper option?

very good team, 9/10

but please dont repost it many times, youl get many chances to post on other threads...
not sure bout Adcock...
Not sure about starting Day... whos Charman? i'd get at least a minimum of petrie in your rucks,
excellent forwards!!

I'm Glad, Luigi.

PS: lol the name of your thread is very similiar to my one,

Yeah alrite thanks for the comments mate. It is quite similar will change now

Quote from: sinclair39 on December 16, 2010, 10:05:09 PM
Yeah alrite thanks for the comments mate. It is quite similar will change now

;) thnx

Your first team is easily the best. 8/10 for that one. ;D

your first side is the best.  i will rate that.

backs: No problem at all with it.

mids: not sure about wallis, may not get too many games under eadey.  get maybe atley, (cheap as) or hallahan or josh green. -0.5.

rucks: no problems there.

fwds: ditch tom lynch.  KPP and very expensive.  try and get isaac smith. -0.5.

Overall very nice team, with a bit of tweaking could be even better.

9/10.

can you rate mine?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23368.0.html (http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23368.0.html)

Quote from: sinclair39 on December 10, 2010, 12:51:54 PM
(At the moment 12/5/9/7)

Back: Goddard*, Hodge*, Kelly*, Adcock, Otten, Heppel*, Tape
(Mzungu, Toy, Richardson)
Mid: Swan, Judd, Montagna, Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Atley, Wallis, Krakeour)
Ruck: Sandilands, Jolly
(Mcdonald^, Z.Smith)
Fwd: Riewoldt, Didak, Pavlich, Rioli, Knights, Petrie^, Prestia
(I.Smith, Lamb, Darling)

* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^= Ruck/Forward MPP

Please post thought out of 10 and what I can improve on

New Side looking for depth here

Back: Goddard*, Hodge*, Kelly*, Grimes, Adcock, Otten, Heppel*
(Mzungu, Toy, Richardson)
Mid: Swan, Judd, Anthony, Ward, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Atley, Wallis, Krakeour)
Ruck: Sandilands, Jolly
(Mcdonald^, Z.Smith)
Fwd: Riewoldt, Didak, Pavlich, Rioli, Knights, Petrie^, Prestia
(I.Smith, Lamb, Darling)

* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^= Ruck/Forward MPP

backs: dont like grimes, though you would have two lions, i would get drummond instead, loving how you have adcock.  -0.5

mids: not sure about Ward. Though he is unique, there are better options such as foley. -0.5

rucks: all good.

fwds: all good.

overall, very good team, 9/10

can you rate my updated side?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23368.0.html (http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,23368.0.html)

Quote from: sinclair39 on December 10, 2010, 12:51:54 PM
(At the moment 11/7/5/10 with $26,200 left)

Back: Goddard*, Gibbs*, Deledio*, Gilbert" Adcock, Otten, Jacobs*
(Puopolo, Toy, Hibberd)
Mid: Swan, Montagna, Boyd, Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Heppell*, Atley, Mzungu^)
Ruck: Sandilands, Day~
(Lycett, Z.Smith)
Fwd: N.Riewoldt, Didak^, Pavlich^, Rioli, Knights, Petrie~, Prestia^
(Talia", Richardson, Darling)

" = Defence/Foward MPP
* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^ = Centre/Foward MPP
~= Ruck/Forward MPP

Please post thought out of 10 and what I can improve on

Quote from: sinclair39 on January 15, 2011, 06:17:45 PM

Quote from: sinclair39 on December 10, 2010, 12:51:54 PM
(At the moment 11/7/5/10 with $26,200 left)

Back: Goddard*, Gibbs*, Deledio*, Gilbert" Adcock, Otten, Jacobs*
(Puopolo, Toy, Hibberd)
Mid: Swan, Montagna, Boyd, Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Heppell*, Atley, Mzungu^)
Ruck: Sandilands, Day~
(Lycett, Z.Smith)
Fwd: N.Riewoldt, Didak^, Pavlich^, Rioli, Knights, Petrie~, Prestia^
(Talia", Richardson, Darling)

" = Defence/Foward MPP
* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^ = Centre/Foward MPP
~= Ruck/Forward MPP

Please post thought out of 10 and what I can improve on

looks fair enough now, though a bit dodgy with starting Day

Yeh your right so in this new side ive put Jolly back in

Quote from: sinclair39 on December 10, 2010, 12:51:54 PM
(At the moment 12/5/10/6 with $14,700 left)

Back: Goddard*, Gibbs*, Deledio*, Gilbert" Adcock, Otten, Jacobs*
(Watson, Toy, Hibberd)
Mid: Swan, Montagna, Boyd, D.Swallow, Gaff, Heppell*
(Wallis, Atley, Mzungu^)
Ruck: Sandilands, Jolly
(McDonald, Z.Smith)
Fwd: N.Riewoldt, Didak^, Pavlich^, Rioli, Knights, Petrie~, Prestia^
(Talia", Richardson, Darling)

" = Defence/Foward MPP
* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^ = Centre/Foward MPP
~= Ruck/Forward MPP

Please post thought out of 10 and what I can improve on

Quote from: tom_scully on December 10, 2010, 11:03:35 PM
who the hell are lester & mcdonald?
Judd? Remember the brownlow curse

No  :P and neither does Robert Harvey  ;)

Quote from: sinclair39 on December 10, 2010, 12:51:54 PM
(At the moment 12/5/10/6 with $14,700 left)

Back: Goddard*, Gibbs*, Deledio*, Gilbert" Adcock, Otten, Jacobs*
(Coad, Toy, Hibberd)
Mid: Swan, Montagna, Boyd, Anthony, D.Swallow, Gaff
(Heppel, Atley, Mzungu^)
Ruck: Sandilands, Petrie~
(Lycett, Z.Smith)
Fwd: N.Riewoldt, Didak^, Pavlich^, Rioli, Knights, Prestia^, I.Smith
(Talia", Richardson, T.McDonald~)

" = Defence/Foward MPP
* = Defence/Midfield MPP
^ = Centre/Foward MPP
~= Ruck/Forward MPP

Please post thought out of 10 and what I can improve on

9/10 from me

minuses for two mid-pricers indefence
lack of super premium in mids
rest is fine

and rookies will change anyway


Luigi :)