please rate!!! feel as this is going to be my side come round one....

Catani92 · March 15, 2013, 11:41:28 AM

Here is what i am hoping will be my final team (i have been changing it like a mad man over this past week) but any feed back on changes would be great
THANKS!!!

BACKS

Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Newman, Goodes, Stevenson (Docherty,Terlich)

MIDFIELD

Ablett (C), Pendlebury(VC), Kennedy, Shuey, Fyfe, Wines, Crouch, O'Meara (Mitchell, Viney)

RUCKS
Mumford,Longer (Rowe, Currie)

FORWARDS
Cox, Rockliff, N. Riewoldt, Wright, Karnezis, Macaffer, B ( Byrnes, Neade)

Only have $100 left in the bank...

FactHunt · March 15, 2013, 02:33:22 PM

I like it mate. Nice balance.

Good PODs in NRoo, Newman, Shuey and Wright. Longer is nicely considered for an upgrade target.

Good-luck.

Catani92 · March 15, 2013, 05:30:34 PM

Don't be shy tell me what your think and leave a link and I will rate your team

spasticnut · March 15, 2013, 05:49:44 PM

I'm counting 12 premiums if you're lucky. Wright and Karnezis are big risks imo. 7/10

Toodles · March 15, 2013, 05:52:37 PM

Good solid looking midfield with all the good rookies in there too!

Byrnes is a waste of money imo.

Catani92 · March 15, 2013, 06:01:25 PM

I picked Byrnes just as a back up along that line just cos of the lack of good rookies in the fwd line and I don't see him getting the vest like maybe neade will and for the $$$

Regs81 · March 15, 2013, 06:41:38 PM

I really like your team.. Here's some points that I would look at, but it's only my opinion.

BACKS: I like, but hartlett is out for first few rounds. And I think there is
Better options than Newman

Rucks: not sure longer will get much game time with Martin there now

Mids: not sold on fyfe, not sure he's body can hold up. Good POD with shuey

FOR: not a big fan of N. Reiwoldt, and if your picking Byrnes he should
Be on the ground. Change either karnezis / Byrnes for a rookie

Catani92 · March 15, 2013, 06:52:16 PM

Went NROO as the saints have a easy first four rounds and then I am going to trade home to stevie j come round 5 when the cats play the dogs.
Picked Byrnes and karnezis as there is not a lot of good rookies on the forward line and these two could easily adv 75-80 and could easily turn into premiums down the track...
Who do you think I should change Newman and fyfe to both shown a bit in NAB
Is hartlett injured?

jackel82 · March 15, 2013, 07:01:09 PM

N. Riewoldt is a pod, risky but I wouldnt say bad. I really like him as a player.
There are a few risks in the rest of the team but your logic is sound. pretty good effort I recon,
8/10

Regs81 · March 15, 2013, 07:04:57 PM

For Newman I would get either teddy Richards, Daniel Merritt or
Even atley to make some cash
Keep fyfe in, unless u can get some more cash and then upgrade
With hartlett, I heard he was injured, but I might be mistaken.. He is
Very injury prone tho. Maybe duffield or Hanley could be better options

tyhwu · March 15, 2013, 09:53:11 PM

like the POD in shuey, but im a bit iffy about your rucks. dunno if mummy can be counted on as R1, longer a good choice but will have to see how it works with martin in the picture now. he seems to be going ok in the final tonight.

Catani92 · March 16, 2013, 12:28:09 AM

I liked Atley at the start of the year and he was in d4 a few times so far in my draft I was impressed with him after NAB 1 but since then hasn't really done much but if I had the cash I would upgrade hartlett to duffield and mummy to a sole Rick man like Maric, but in saying that mummy and Newman both have a history of being premiums and with new mans new role on the wing I don't see why he can not adv 90 again!!

Catani92 · March 16, 2013, 10:34:30 AM

Was thinking about the Newman to atley and hartlett to Hanley and pitting the cash into my r1 but I can only generate 35,000 and can not buy Jacobs :( I can afford Giles which could be a good pod but I not real keen haha . So do I leave mummy in at r1 as Sydney play GWS, Gold Coast ,north Melbourne and Geelong in the first four rounds and is guaranteed to make some $$$ then trade him to a Maric or Jacobs who will adv 100 :)

Blues Blues Blues · March 16, 2013, 01:19:14 PM

I like the team, especially if Shuey, Fyfe and NRoo can fire. Same predicament as me, do you go 4 premo in defence and 1 premo ruck, or 3 def and set/forget rucks.

If concerned about Hartlett, maybe downgrade Byrnes and upgrade Hartlett to Duffman, or pick Hanley.

Good luck

Keano · March 16, 2013, 05:31:09 PM

I really like this team!
However i think maybe a Mundy or Gaff would be a better option over the injury ridden Fyfe.
I also think you should get Rid of Byrnes for a rookie and with that extra 100,000 upgrade Newman to Heppel and also try and upgrade Wright to Bartel.
Overall very good though